Labor rights activists and business leaders with experience working in China agree that signing a trade agreement between Taiwan and China would speed up capital outflow from the nation, but their opinions differ on solving Taiwan’s unemployment problem.
A proposed economic cooperation framework agreement (ECFA) with China “would speed up outflow of domestic capital and the exodus of businesses and it will not solve the unemployment problem,” Victims of Investment in China Association (VICA) president William Kao (高為邦) said.
The core problem of the nation’s shrinking economy is that Taiwanese businesses have lost their competitive edge on the global stage and that will not be solved by signing an ECFA, Kao argued, saying that Taiwanese business leaders had no choice but to move to China or other countries with cheaper labor.
Moreover, Kao said, China is not trustworthy and many Taiwanese have been stripped of their property and assets in China by the Chinese government, which has used “every method imaginable.”
Kao himself is an example.
A group of unidentified men looted his Chinese factory in 1999. After asking the Chinese government for help to no avail for two years, he left China in 2001.
The government claims signing an ECFA will create 260,000 jobs, although the opposition says there could be as many as 890,000 jobs lost after it is signed, he said.
“The real answer is probably something in between,” Kao said.
With 600,000 people out of work, unemployment is the most serious issue in the nation, he said. Unless the government removes the minimum wage requirement for foreign workers, there will not be a solution to the unemployment problem, Kao said.
“A problematic foreign labor policy enacted in 1992 is the root cause of all these problems,” he said.
If the minimum wage of foreign workers was lowered and businesses were allowed to hire as many as 60 percent foreign workers, companies would be willing to move back to Taiwan, given China’s inconsistent policies, investment environment and worsening social order, Kao said.
“That would create more jobs for local workers,” he said.
“I agree that the ECFA will not solve the unemployment problem, but I find it hard to agree with Kao’s theory,” Taiwan Labor Front secretary-general Sun Yu-lien (孫友聯) said.
An ECFA is basically a free-trade agreement that would only benefit specific sectors or companies, while most small and medium-sized businesses would suffer, Sun said.
“The only thing left in Taiwan would be lower-level service sector companies operating solely for domestic demand, just like what happened in Hong Kong after it signed its Closer Economic Partnership Arrangement [CEPA] with China,” he said.
Sun said Kao’s theory has been brought up by legislators previously, but it had not been implemented by the previous administration or the KMT government.
“It’s obviously not in line with mainstream opinion,” he said.
Sun expressed opposition to the theory because it does not respect labor rights, a universal value, and is against Taiwan’s labor policy that regards foreign labor as a “supplementary” workforce.
“If we agree with the principle of ‘equal pay for equal work’ ... if we agree that men and women should receive the same pay for the same work, then why should foreign workers be different?” Sun asked.
If the minimum wage for foreign workers was lower than that for domestic workers, Sun said it would lead to lower overall payment levels eventually because employers would rather hire cheaper foreign workers than domestic workers.
SEND A MESSAGE: Sinking the amphibious assault ship, the lead warship of its class, is meant to show China the US Navy is capable of sinking their ships, an analyst said The US and allied navies plan to sink a 40,000-tonne ship at the latest Rim of the Pacific (RIMPAC) exercise to simulate defeating a Chinese amphibious assault on Taiwan. This year’s RIMPAC — the 29th iteration of the world’s largest naval exercise — involves the US, 28 partners, more than 25,000 personnel, 40 warships, three submarines and more than 150 aircraft operating in and around Hawaii from yesterday to Aug. 1, the US Navy said in a press release. The major components of the event include multidomain warfare exercises in multiship surface engagements, anti-submarine warfare and multi-axis defense of a carrier strike
Taiwanese could risk being extradited to China when traveling in countries with close ties to Beijing, Taiwan Association of University Professors deputy chairman Chen Li-fu (陳俐甫) said on Friday. Chen’s comments came after China on Friday last week announced new judicial guidelines targeting Taiwanese independence advocates. Myanmar, Cambodia, Laos and Djibouti are among the countries where Taiwanese could risk being extradited to China, he said. The Mainland Affairs Council (MAC) on Thursday elevated the travel alert for China, Hong Kong and Macau to “orange” after Beijing announced its guidelines to “severely punish Taiwanese independence diehards for splitting the country and inciting secession.” Extradition treaties
The airspace around Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport and Taipei International Airport (Songshan airport) is to be closed for an hour on July 25 and July 23 respectively, due to the Han Kuang military exercises, the Ministry of National Defense said yesterday. The annual exercise is to be held on Taiwan proper and its outlying islands from July 22 to 26. During last year’s exercise, the military conducted anti-aircraft landing drills at the Taoyuan airport for the first time, for which a one-hour no-fly ban was issued. Based on a live-fire bulletin sent out by the Maritime and Port Bureau, the nation’s
Taiwan and Thailand have signed an agreement to promote and protect bilateral investment and trade, the Executive Yuan’s Office of Trade Negotiations (OTN) said on Friday. The agreement on “Promotion and Protection of Investments” was signed by Representative to Thailand Chang Chun-fu (張俊福) and Thailand Trade and Economic Office in Taipei executive director Narong Boonsatheanwong on Thursday, the OTN said in a news release. Thailand has become the fifth trading partner to sign an investment agreement with Taiwan since 2016, following earlier agreements with the Philippines, India, Vietnam and Canada, the OTN said. The deal marks a significant milestone in the development of