Sun, Jan 17, 2010 page3

• FEATURE : Pundits not satisfied with government aid to Haiti

  • By Jenny W. hsu / STAFF REPORTER
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  The government’s response to the humanitarian crisis in Haiti is a crucial factor in determining its diplomatic strength, some observers said yesterday, urging the government to show the same level of concern as it did for China during the Sichuan Earthquake of 2008.

  Three days after a 7.5 magnitude earthquake struck the Chinese province on May 12, 2008, the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) administration announced a financial package of US$60 million.

  Public servants were requested to donate a day’s salary to the relief effort, and Taiwan’s rescuers were among the first international teams to reach China.

  Local charity groups mobilized fundraising efforts and unprecedented donations totaling in the billions of dollars flooded in from the corporate world.

  The entertainment industry banded together to collect money, producing the song Heart that Can’t be Shattered in a show of sympathy and support. Stars such as Jolin Tsai (蔡依林) and Mayday (五月天), along with then-president-elect Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) and his wife Chou Mei-ching (周美青) answered phones at a charity telethon.

  Taiwan also responded to the catastrophe that struck a number of countries in late December 2004, when an earthquake triggered a tsunami that killed hundreds of thousands of people.

  The government donated US$50 million in aid.

  None of the countries affected by the tsunami had diplomatic relations with Taiwan.

  Haiti and Taiwan have been allies for 53 years. The death toll after Tuesday’s 7.0 temblor may be as high as 200,000 according to some estimates.

  Three days after the earthquake — the same period of time the former government took to announce a US$60 million aid package to China — the Ma administration pledged US$5 million in cash as well as supplies including rice, drinking water and camping gear.

  No request of one day’s salary has been made to public servants.

  There have been no announcements yet of donations by the corporate world, nor has the entertainment sector used its star power to raise funds. The first lady has not publicly commented on the tragedy.

  The Ministry of Foreign Affairs has not held a press conference on the issue. Statements from the ministry have been released in response to media inquiries or as press releases.

  While some observers warned that the stark contrast in the government’s response could end up hurting Taiwan’s diplomatic future, others said it could be an opportunity for Taiwan to showcase its commitment to human rights and foreign aid.

  National Chengchi University political science professor Yen Chen-shen (嚴震生) said the government’s pledge was “absolutely not enough” and Taiwan should up its donation once the Haitian government is functioning better.

  “The situation is extremely messy and convoluted right now — almost in a state of anarchy. It is wise to wait until the social unrest settles down before we offer more money and discuss long-term rebuilding efforts” he said.

  Yan said that since the Ma administration had declared a “diplomatic truce” — a call for a ceasefire with China on the diplomatic front — Taiwan now feels secure in its ties with its allies.

  But that does not mean Taiwan can “take its friends for granted,” he said, adding that Taiwan should step up efforts to help its allies, especially as the nation no longer needs to engage in a money war with China to compete for recognition.

  Yan suggested that Taiwan find ways to help the Dominican Republic accommodate an expected influx of Haitian refugees.

  Former foreign minister Chen Chien-jen (程建人) said US$5 million was too little and the announcement had come too late.

  Taiwan first pledged US$200,000, then added another US$300,000 one day later before tacking on another US$5 million.

  MOFA said it could increase the figure further.

  Chen criticized the government for waiting a few days before announcing its US$5 million pledge, but said all the right steps were being taken and, if done right, this could be an opportunity for Taiwan to show its strength in humanitarian assistance and human rights.

  Both Chen and Yan said comparing Taiwan’s response to the devastation in China and Haiti would be misleading because Haiti was a unique matter as it is mandatory for Taiwan to maintain a sound relationship with its neighbor, especially during times of despair.

  Lai Yi-chung (賴怡忠), an executive member of Taiwan Thinktank who has formerly served as a DPP official, said the Ma government must not display any preferential treatment when it comes to foreign aid because it could end up hurting the nation’s foreign ties in the long run.

  “The dollar amount does not have to be same, but the level of urgency and concerns that are being extended to Haiti must at least match that shown to China,” he said, adding that while Haiti is a friendly ally, China has missiles pointed at Taiwan.

  Moreover, many of Taiwan’s allies could be monitoring the government’s response as a measuring stick to gauge how Taipei would help them if their country faced a large-scale natural disaster, he said.

  “We need to reassure our allies that despite cross-strait detente, we still view them as important friends and our commitments to them are unwavering. How Taiwan responds to [the crisis in] Haiti sends a loud message to our existing allies as well as other nations,” Lai said.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Two dead as fans, police clash before game in Chile

  • 2

    Taiwan and the US preparing a ‘hellscape’ strategy

  • 3

    Two questioned over DPP legislator recall forgery

  • 4

    Former DPP aide detained in spy probe

  • 5

    Nazi armband protest in recall petition case draws criticism