Mon, Aug 31, 2009 page3

• FEATURE: Tunghsing Building rebuilt but losses, anger linger

  RESPONSIBILITY It took 10 years to reconstruct the only Taipei City building toppled in the 921 Earthquake. Residents blame the city government for the delays and hardships

  • By Mo Yan-chih / STAFF REPORTER
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  In the 10 years since the Tunghsing Building in Taipei City was leveled by the 921 Earthquake in 1999, 68-year-old Mrs. Chien (簡) and most of her fellow residents have been forced to live with relatives or move around while waiting for their home to be reconstructed.

  The rebuilding project, which began in 2004 and was suspended twice because of the contractors’ financial problems, was finally inaugurated on Saturday, with more than 70 of the 84 former households preparing to return to the 14-story building at the intersection of Bade Road and Hulin Street.

  “I’ve been renting apartments in the vicinity since the earthquake. Ten years is a very long time, and I am glad that I can finally move back home,” she said on Saturday while chatting with old neighbors who gathered to attend the inauguration.

  

  Chen Chien-hua, right, former head of the Tunghsing Building Self-help Association, calls on President Ma Ying-jeou to learn from the 921 Earthquake during a blessing ceremony to mark the building’s reconstruction in Taipei on Stauday.

  PHOTO: CHIEN JUNG-FONG, TAIPEI TIMES

  The memory of the night of the massive earthquake, which killed more than 2,400 people, remains vivid for Chien. She and her husband were sleeping in their 10th floor apartment, and they managed to escape through the air conditioning vents as the whole building collapsed in seconds, she said.

  The Tunghsiung Building was the only structure in Taipei City to be completely destroyed by the quake, which was centered about 200km outside the city. Eighty-seven people in the building were killed, 105 injured and more than 250 left homeless in the collapse.

  While other collapsed buildings around the country were rebuilt over the years, the road to reconstruction was a bumpy one for Tunghsing’s residents. The project was halted twice after two contractors declared bankruptcy, one in 2006 and the other last year, while a lawsuit filed by survivors against the Taipei City Government was an additional financial burden on those residents.

  In 2000, the residents filed a NT$1.5 billion (US$45 million) lawsuit against the city for issuing an operation license to the original contractor despite the building’s substandard construction. Then-Taipei mayor Ma Ying-jeou’s (馬英九) administration refused to admit responsibility for the collapse, but the Taiwan High Court ruled in 2005 that the city must pay NT$330 million to the residents. The city appealed the ruling.

  The legal war between the city and the residents remained unsettled until 2007, when Taipei Mayor Hau Lung-bin (郝龍斌) agreed to pay the residents NT$120 million.

  Catherine Liao (廖汶錡), director of Tunghsing Building Reconstruction Association, said the residents had mixed feelings about the 10-year reconstruction process, but she declined to comment on the lawsuit.

  “We remain thankful for the city government’s administrative assistance,” she said.

  Chen Chien-hua (陳建華), a member of Tunghsing Building Self-help Association, however, criticized Ma as indifferent to the residents’ pain and incapable of handling the aftermath of the building’s collapse.

  “It took President Ma Ying-jeou 10 years to rebuild the Tunghsing Building. Let’s wait and see how many years he needs to rebuild the areas hard-hit by Typhoon Morakot,” he said.

  Chen, who lost his mother and brother in the 921 Earthquake, said the time-consuming lawsuit and the delays in the reconstruction process resulted in a NT$100 million construction surcharge, forcing each household to pay several million NT dollars in addition to their original mortgage.

  Liao said about 90 percent of residents had not moved back into building because of paperwork and mortgage issues. The paperwork process and mortgage negotiation with banks and the contractor could take months.

  Chien is one of the lucky few who will be moving back in soon. She will be back on the 10th floor, but just with her son because her husband passed away seven months ago.

  “My biggest regret is that my husband did not live to see the new building and return home with me,” she said.

  Chen said if the former Ma administration had used its power to help facilitate the reconstruction process, instead of challenging the residents in a legal fight, the building would have been rebuilt years ago, saving residents time and money.

  Lin Chung-huan (林崇煥), director of the city’s Urban Redevelopment Office, said the city government had given subsidies to the residents and negotiated with the central government to win the residents lower interest rates on their mortgages.

  The office will hold a meeting with Ministry of Interior’s Construction and Planning Agency tomorrow to discuss ways to facilitate the remaining paperwork.

  When asked about the mortgage issue and the construction surcharge, Lin said the surcharge was caused by the rising price of construction materials in recent years.

  “The city government has no responsibility for the mortgages and surcharge. It is the residents’ job to negotiate with the banks and pay the money,” he said.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Two dead as fans, police clash before game in Chile

  • 2

    Taiwan and the US preparing a ‘hellscape’ strategy

  • 3

    Two questioned over DPP legislator recall forgery

  • 4

    Former DPP aide detained in spy probe

  • 5

    Nazi armband protest in recall petition case draws criticism