The failure of both UN membership referendums could block Taiwan's attempt to participate in international organizations, but may also present an opportunity to reform the referendum system, political observers said.
"The international community may misinterpret what the failure of both referendums means," said Herman Chiang (江岷欽), a public administration professor at Taipei University. "We may think the referendums are not important, but it may have an impact on our future attempts to join international organizations."
On top of serving as a record of what the public thinks on certain subjects, "referendums are used in Taiwan as a tool for political mobilization -- the Democratic Progressive Party [DPP] used its referendum to boost support, while the Chinese Nationalist Party [KMT] used theirs as a counter-mechanism," he said.
PHOTO: YANG MEI-HUNG, TAIPEI TIMES
Lacking a close understanding of the political and social context in the nation, "Western countries may misunderstand the mainstream public opinion in Taiwan," Chiang said.
Tseng Chien-yuan (
"Since even the more conservative option of the two referendum prepositions -- the KMT's `return to the UN' -- did not pass, it will be a problem for the new government to tell the international community what the Taiwanese people really want."
One challenge for the new president will therefore be to explain to the world the real meaning behind the failure of the referendums, Tseng said.
"We have to follow closely how [KMT president elect] Ma Ying-jeou [馬英九] explains to the international community that we long for participation in global affairs," Chiang said.
On the other hand, National Taiwan University political science professor Ger Yeong-kuang (
"[The failure of referendums] will neither have an impact on domestic politics, nor on our participation in international affairs," Ger said.
"For domestic politics, nothing happened when the referendums failed last time," he said. "As for our participating in international organizations, we wouldn't have been accepted right away if the referendums passed and we will continue our efforts even though the referendums fail."
What is of greater importance, Ger said, is for the new president to find a way to make a breakthrough in cross-strait and international relations.
Another concern for observers were potential reforms to the referendum system.
"It would mean that the referendum system is stable if at least one of the referendums passes," Tseng said ahead of the vote.
The outcome, however, went the other way.
"We surely need a reform in the system -- the referendum thresholds may need to be lowered so that the power to make a referendum initiative can really be given back to the people," Chiang said.
"The referendum should no longer be a tool for political mobilization. It's an insult to the system," he said.
While also optimistic about reforms, Tseng said he was worried about the future direction they would take.
"With the KMT dominance [in legislature], the reform may go in the direction of banning the grouping of referendums with elections," he said.
If such a reform occured, it would hurt the referendum system and would be a step backward for democracy, he said.
Eric Suy-Verburg, former under-secretary for the UN's Office of Legal Affairs, said that the DPP referendum "for the time being, is unrealistic."
"In previous UN general assemblies, there were always the same reactions [to reject Taiwan's bid] because of obstruction from the People's Republic of China," he said.
The KMT version, he said, was a bit more "balanced" because it does not call for the rigidity of only applying for full UN membership under a particular name, unlike the one pitched by the DPP.
However, the seasoned politician from Beligum said "there is never a `never' in international politics" and that "things may change."
"Taiwan should find new ways, new avenues and new openings [in its UN bids]. And it should make more friends that support its position. Be patient," he said.
Bruno Kaufmann, president of the Germany-based Initiative and Referendum Institute Europe, questioned if the referendum, as a mechanism for people to express their will, is being fully and correctly used by Taiwanese.
During his tour of polling booths yesterday, Kaufmann noticed that some people were subtly discouraging people from casting referendum ballots by ushering the voters straight to the polling booth, bypassing the table where they could pick up the referendum ballots.
He lamented that neither referendum had succeeded because it only "educates the people not to participate and it rewards the non-participants."
People will become disinterested and jaded about referendums as a mechanism if they persistently see that their affirmative votes do not count, he said.
Eva Tseng (鄭心瑜), a member of the Washington-based lobbist group Formosa Association for Public Affairs' youth group, said that the recent US denounciations of the referendums may have been a major factor in people's apathy toward them.
"It is unfair that the US had a say in the democratic process of another nation," she said.
The Mainland Affairs Council (MAC) today condemned the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) after the Czech officials confirmed that Chinese agents had surveilled Vice President Hsiao Bi-khim (蕭美琴) during her visit to Prague in March last year. Czech Military Intelligence director Petr Bartovsky yesterday said that Chinese operatives had attempted to create the conditions to carry out a demonstrative incident involving Hsiao, going as far as to plan a collision with her car. Hsiao was vice president-elect at the time. The MAC said that it has requested an explanation and demanded a public apology from Beijing. The CCP has repeatedly ignored the desires
Many Chinese spouses required to submit proof of having renounced their Chinese household registration have either completed the process or provided affidavits ahead of the June 30 deadline, the Mainland Affairs Council (MAC) said on Thursday. Of the 12,146 people required to submit the proof, 5,534 had done so as of Wednesday, MAC deputy head and spokesperson Liang Wen-chieh (梁文傑) said. Another 2,572 people who met conditions for exemption or deferral from submitting proof of deregistration — such as those with serious illnesses or injuries — have submitted affidavits instead, he said. “As long as individuals are willing to cooperate with the legal
The Ma-anshan Nuclear Power Plant’s license has expired and it cannot simply be restarted, the Executive Yuan said today, ahead of national debates on the nuclear power referendum. The No. 2 reactor at the Ma-anshan Nuclear Power Plant in Pingtung County was disconnected from the nation’s power grid and completely shut down on May 17, the day its license expired. The government would prioritize people’s safety and conduct necessary evaluations and checks if there is a need to extend the service life of the reactor, Executive Yuan spokeswoman Michelle Lee (李慧芝) told a news conference. Lee said that the referendum would read: “Do
The Ministry of Environment yesterday held a seminar in Taipei for experts from Taiwan and Japan to exchange their experiences on the designs and development of public toilets. Japan Toilet Association chairman Kohei Yamamoto said that he was impressed with the eco-toilet set up at Daan Forest Park, adding that Japan still faces issues regarding public restrooms despite the progress it made over the past decades. For example, an all-gender toilet was set up in Kabukicho in Tokyo’s Shinjuku District several years ago, but it caused a public backlash and was rebuilt into traditional men’s and women’s toilets, he said. Japan Toilet Association
RSS