Both the legislative speaker and his deputy, as well as most caucus whips, are on the edge of failing or have failed in their legislative duties in the past two legislative terms, according to a report released by the Taipei Society yesterday.
The Taipei Society reviewed the performances of all lawmakers in the fourth and fifth terms of the fifth legislature.
According to the report, 43 lawmakers failed in their duties in the past two terms and 59 are on the group's probation list for near failure.
They contain almost 50 percent of all lawmakers. Seven of the Non-Partisan Solidarity Union's 11 lawmakers -- 63.6 percent -- are listed among the 43 lawmakers failing in their duties.
"The criteria for failing are: failing to attend more than half of all committee sessions or appearing in two negative indexes out of the three we set," said Chang Mao-kuei (
The three negative indexes were: having been charged with a crime or sentenced, having conflicting interests and badmouthing other lawmakers or getting involved in physical conflicts. If a lawmaker attended more than half of the committee sessions but was listed in one negative index, their name was put on the probation list, Chang said.
The Taipei Society's list of lawmakers with conflicting interests includes 71 people, or about one-third of all lawmakers.
A conflict of interest was defined as owning or chairing the board of a company that might conflict with legislative duties, or being married to someone who holds such a post.
"Various surveys have shown that the legislature is the root of chaos: Almost half of the lawmakers have failed us, and at least one-third of the lawmakers have not avoided conflicts of interest, but the public could not see through that," said Lyu Hsiu-chu (
Both Legislative Speaker Wang Jin-pyng (
Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) caucus whip Tseng Yung-chuan (曾永權) was judged to have failed, while three People First Party caucus whips in the fourth and fifth terms were put on the probation list for different reasons.
The society also compiled a list of 39 lawmakers (18.1 percent) it considered to be relatively positive.
These include KMT caucus whip Huang Teh-fu (
The criteria for the list of positive lawmakers were signing up for at least two-thirds of the committee sessions and not being listed in a negative index.
The society's lists have been met with criticism from lawmakers, as well as reporters.
Reporters have expressed doubts among themselves about a few names on the relatively positive list because some of those praised by the Taipei Society have histories of controversial performances in previous legislative terms or had conflicts of interest.
A number of lawmakers, especially those who have been named as failures or out on the probation list, have ruthlessly criticized the Taipei Society, some even describing it as "blind."
"If the Taipei Society wants to conduct evaluations of the law-makers, it should do it regularly every one or two terms. It should not have released the report just before the election, which could manipulate the results," Huang said.
PFP Legislator Hsieh Chang-chieh (謝章捷), the PFP caucus whip in the fifth term, said that he and his colleague PFP legislator-at-large Lee Tung-hao (李桐豪) did not deserve to be put on the failing list.
"Is the Taipei Society blind? It lists Lee, a model lawmaker, as failing in his duties," Hsieh said.
Hsieh was listed as failing because of his low participation rate in the committee sessions.
Lee's listing might have been the result of a misunderstanding on the part of the Taipei Society. He was penalized for saying that anyone could try to assassinate President Chen Shui-bian (
The society issued a press release later yesterday announcing that it was taking Lee off the list.
In response to the Non-Partisan Solidarity Union's high percentage of failing lawmakers, the union's caucus whip Yen Ching-piao (顏清標) said that constituency service would be a more important reflection of a lawmaker's performance.
"Many lawmakers only signed up when the committee session started and left right away, and they did not necessarily join the discussions in the committee. A report based on the sign-up rate is not objective," Yen said.
"The most important thing is for a lawmaker to secure funds for necessary constituency constructions," he said.
A decision to describe a Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs statement on Singapore’s Taiwan policy as “erroneous” was made because the city-state has its own “one China policy” and has not followed Beijing’s “one China principle,” Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Tien Chung-kwang (田中光) said yesterday. It has been a longstanding practice for the People’s Republic of China (PRC) to speak on other countries’ behalf concerning Taiwan, Tien said. The latest example was a statement issued by the PRC after a meeting between Singaporean Prime Minister Lawrence Wong (黃循財) and Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) on the sidelines of the APEC summit
Taiwan’s passport ranked 34th in the world, with access to 141 visa-free destinations, according to the latest update to the Henley Passport Index released today. The index put together by Henley & Partners ranks 199 passports globally based on the number of destinations holders can access without a visa out of 227, and is updated monthly. The 141 visa-free destinations for Taiwanese passport holders are a slight decrease from last year, when holders had access to 145 destinations. Botswana and Columbia are among the countries that have recently ended visa-free status for Taiwanese after “bowing to pressure from the Chinese government,” the Ministry
HEALTHCARE: Following a 2022 Constitutional Court ruling, Taiwanese traveling overseas for six months would no longer be able to suspend their insurance Measures allowing people to suspend National Health Insurance (NHI) services if they plan to leave the country for six months would be abolished starting Dec. 23, NHIA Director-General Shih Chung-liang (石崇良) said yesterday. The decision followed the Constitutional Court’s ruling in 2022 that the regulation was unconstitutional and that it would invalidate the regulation automatically unless the NHIA amended it to conform with the Constitution. The agency would amend the regulations to remove the articles and sections that allow the suspension of NHI services, and also introduce provisional clauses for those who suspended their NHI services before Dec. 23, Shih said. According to
Minister of Labor Ho Pei-shan (何佩珊) yesterday apologized after the suicide of a civil servant earlier this month and announced that a supervisor accused of workplace bullying would be demoted. On Nov. 4, a 39-year-old information analyst at the Workforce Development Agency’s (WDA) northern branch, which covers greater Taipei and Keelung, as well as Yilan, Lienchiang and Kinmen counties, was found dead in their office. WDA northern branch director Hsieh Yi-jung (謝宜容), who has been accused of involvement in workplace bullying, would be demoted to a nonsupervisory position, Ho told a news conference in Taipei. WDA Director-General Tsai Meng-liang (蔡孟良) said he would
RSS