In recent years, the National Health Insurance program (NHI) has faced mounting financial woes, leading to talk of increasing premiums and plans by the Bureau of National Health Insurance to exclude certain non-essential medication from NHI coverage.
In an exclusive interview with the Taipei Times, Fritz Britt, head of the Novartis Policy Office, Novartis AG, and Stefan Ziegler, Novartis Asia-Pacific regional head, talked about their thoughts on Taiwan's NHI system and how it compares with European health care systems.
Analyzing the cost distribution of the NHI, Britt said that he felt Taiwan was very "hospital heavy," meaning that the system favors the hospitals.
PHOTO COURTESY OF NOVARTIS
"Hospitals tend to be pretty expensive. In all the health systems I have seen, if you have [a scenario in which] you shift power to one of the players, then it's going to be more of a power game than a real balanced system. My experience of European systems is that you would rather have a balanced hospital and [clinic] system," Britt said.
According to Britt, 20 years ago in France the trend was the same, with hospitals tending to grow ever bigger. As a result, regulations were brought in to restrict hospitals to a certain growth rate. Britt said in comparison, hospitals in European countries such as France, Italy, Spain and Germany are far more closely controlled by the state, and subject to far more regulation.
"We don't want to jeopardize [clinics] because it's the [combination of hospitals and clinics] that makes treatment cost-efficient, and not [a health care system] in which the hospitals have a monopoly," Britt said.
PHOTO COURTESY OF NOVARTIS
Pointing to another "bucket" of costs, Britt talked about how Taiwan's NHI covers a broader range of services than other, more established systems in which services are more narrowly defined.
"Even in France or Italy -- the traditional total coverage systems -- they are now saying that [certain] treatments are privately paid for, that they are not covered by the reimbursement system. In the drug field, these are the over-the-counter drugs, the drugs for coughs colds, headaches -- the day-to-day types of drugs," Britt said. He went on to suggest that a good move for Taiwan would be to have some non-essential drugs being paid for "out of pocket."
"[Taking] these treatments out of the system means you free up money for the really costly interventions. This way you can really get rid of the financial pressure," Britt said.
Aside from regulatory changes, Britt and Zeigler emphasized the role which investment plays in cost containment.
"If you look around, the companies which survive are not only cutting costs, they are also investing in opportunities," Britt said.
By way of example, Britt pointed out that although advances in medical treatment and new types of drugs are expensive, they help to offset costs in other areas by reducing the length of hospital visits and keeping NHI members in the workforce.
"Innovation is probably the key to overall cost containment," he explained.
In Europe, where cost-cutting has been taken about as far as possible, efforts are being made to improve working methods and to use treatments and drugs that lead to shorter treatment loops.
Britt and Ziegler stressed that cost containment rather than cost-cutting was the goal, since with the increase in the number of diseases and the ageing population it was natural that the health system should grow -- preferably at a proportionate rate to the GDP.
According to Britt, in 2002 the percentage of health care expenditure as a percentage of GDP in Taiwan was 6 percent, which compares favourably to European countries where the figure is typically between 8-10 percent.
"The question is: 'What is the right proportion?' Most countries try to be between 8-10 percent of GDP," Britt said, explaining that where the proportion of health expenditure to GDP was higher than 10 percent, the health outcome wasn't necessarily visibly better.
However, in those countries where the figure is below 8 percent -- such as certain countries in Africa, Poland, or Hungary -- problems with the quality of health care result.
Ziegler explained that health expenditure as a percentage of GDP reflected things such as doctors per capita, hospital beds per capita and the time it takes to see a doctor.
"When you go below 8-10 percent of GDP it means you start to take infrastructure out of the system; you take a hospital out of the system, you take a [clinic] out of the system. When you decide [to do] this, you take that money and you put it somewhere else." Ziegler said, adding that such choices were conscious political decisions that affected the quality of health care.
Speaking about general recommendations for Taiwan's system, Britt said: "Taiwan needs a Taiwanese system. You can't copy another system -- there is no economically correct system."
Britt went on to explain that a system that worked in one country couldn't be guaranteed to work in another, since each has different starting points.
Britt referred to the Swiss health care system -- the only such system in Europe that is not bankrupt, according to Britt -- as an example. He said that a similar system couldn't be implemented elsewhere due to cultural differences and the fact that people would fight the changes.
Ziegler concluded by saying that what was important for Taiwan was that there should be a "vision" going forward.
"Say the vision 5-10 years down the road is a natural mix between private payments, private insurance systems, government insurance ? then you can work towards that."
AIR DEFENSE: The Norwegian missile system has proved highly effective in Ukraine in its war against Russia, and the US has recommended it for Taiwan, an expert said The Norwegian Advanced Surface-to-Air Missile Systems (NASAMS) Taiwan ordered from the US would be installed in strategically important positions in Taipei and New Taipei City to guard the region, the Ministry of National Defense said in statement yesterday. The air defense system would be deployed in Taipei’s Songshan District (松山) and New Taipei City’s Tamsui District (淡水), the ministry said, adding that the systems could be delivered as soon as the end of this year. The US Defense Security Cooperation Agency has previously said that three NASAMS would be sold to Taiwan. The weapons are part of the 17th US arms sale to
SERIOUS ALLEGATIONS: The suspects formed spy networks and paramilitary groups to kill government officials during a possible Chinese invasion, prosecutors said Prosecutors have indicted seven retired military officers, members of the Rehabilitation Alliance Party, for allegedly obtaining funds from China, and forming paramilitary groups and assassination squads in Taiwan to collaborate with Chinese troops in a possible war. The suspects contravened the National Security Act (國家安全法) by taking photos and drawing maps of key radar stations, missile installations and the American Institute in Taiwan’s headquarters in Taipei, prosecutors said. They allegedly prepared to collaborate with China during a possible invasion of Taiwan, prosecutors said. Retired military officer Chu Hung-i (屈宏義), 62, a Republic of China Army Academy graduate, went to China
INSURRECTION: The NSB said it found evidence the CCP was seeking snipers in Taiwan to target members of the military and foreign organizations in the event of an invasion The number of Chinese spies prosecuted in Taiwan has grown threefold over a four-year period, the National Security Bureau (NSB) said in a report released yesterday. In 2021 and 2022, 16 and 10 spies were prosecuted respectively, but that number grew to 64 last year, it said, adding that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) was working with gangs in Taiwan to develop a network of armed spies. Spies in Taiwan have on behalf of the CCP used a variety of channels and methods to infiltrate all sectors of the country, and recruited Taiwanese to cooperate in developing organizations and obtaining sensitive information
BREAKTHROUGH: The US is making chips on par in yield and quality with Taiwan, despite people saying that it could not happen, the official said Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) has begun producing advanced 4-nanometer (nm) chips for US customers in Arizona, US Secretary of Commerce Gina Raimondo said, a milestone in the semiconductor efforts of the administration of US President Joe Biden. In November last year, the commerce department finalized a US$6.6 billion grant to TSMC’s US unit for semiconductor production in Phoenix, Arizona. “For the first time ever in our country’s history, we are making leading edge 4-nanometer chips on American soil, American workers — on par in yield and quality with Taiwan,” Raimondo said, adding that production had begun in recent
RSS