The revised Agriculture Development Act now sitting in the legislature -- the brainchild of the Council of Agriculture under Chairman Peng Tso-kwei (
A 'Pandora's box'
Standing firm on his decision to step down from office, Peng yesterday sternly criticized the government's relaxing regulations over Taiwan's agricultural land-use policy.
PHOTO: GEORGE TSORNG, TAIPEI TIMES
"It would be like opening a Pandora's box," he said, referring to a host of potential problems, such as renewed land speculation, overdevelopment, the further erosion of Taiwan's environment and the disappearance of the remaining land actually used to grow crops on.
In fact, the revised version of the Agriculture Development Act, drafted by Peng's agency, differs in only one respect: the controversial article over whether or not to allow houses to be built on newly-sold farm land. The Cabinet version stipulates that only community-style subdivision housing be permitted, while the KMT's new proposal would allow individual homes to be built.
The Cabinet's version of the bill includes two other major proposals: opening up the market for agricultural land (
Aides to Peng have criticized the three articles describing them as a three-legged table, which, once one leg has been damaged, the whole structure will be brought to the ground.
Analysts say, however, that reform on the free trade of farm land must be undertaken in order to introduce both capital and modern technology into agriculture as Taiwan nears entry into the WTO.
They said even Peng agreed about that.
However, the core of the issue, according to Peng, lies in housing development.
"If barriers to lowering the price of agricultural land are dropped, and people are allowed to subdivide it into portions, and if we begin granting permission to build on newly purchased farm land, I'm afraid that agricultural land will be washed away on a massive scale," Peng said.
Critics also worried that if the ban on building farm houses on newly sold agricultural land is lifted, some land, especially those plots located in city suburbs, will be swallowed up by conglomerates. Furthermore, they said, in the name of building farm houses, they may actually feed the trend of mansion-style housing complexes.
"This would also endanger the progress of our agricultural modernization," Peng said.
To consolidate his policy position, Peng raised other questions regarding the KMT legislative caucus' alternative proposal.
"If every single farm plot becomes full of farm houses, we can neither proceed with large scale hi-tech agricultural cultivation, nor spray insecticide from the air," Peng said.
While saying they understood Peng's argument, representatives from local farmer's associations said that as long as the ban continues on building new housing on farm land, there is no incentive for anyone to purchase agricultural land.
"If the cabinet does not lift the ban on housing construction on farm land, I believe there would not be enough incentive for buyers," said Wu Ming-hui (吳銘輝), an official from the Taichung County Farmer's Association.
"Whether building a brand new complex or leaving a boundless green field, the contribution to the village is the same," Wu added.
Local farm leaders said that while they understood where Peng's policy was coming from, they had no choice but to consider their self interest first.
Lin Jing-yuan (
"If a farmer can count on earning a living on his land, then no farmer would want to sell his land," he said.
Farming doesn't pay
The statement reveals a crucial problem in Taiwan's agricultural sector: namely, that farming doesn't pay. According to current statistics, local farmers say that the more crops they actually plant, the more financial losses they accrue, leading to a cycle of debt and massive government subsidies for farmers.
"Farmers are so poor that if farmer associations refuse to grant loans to them, I suspect the banks would also be reluctant to extend credit to land tillers," Lin said.
To further illustrate the fact that agricultural land is worthless as long as current policy holds, Lin pointed to the difficulty of unloading land onto the market.
"We have a plot of farmland in our hands, and we have tried to auction it off at least six times. But nobody wants to buy it," he said.
"I can't imagine who, if the construction of farm houses is prohibited on newly sold agricultural land, would want to buy farmland," Lin said.
Experts, however, have challenged the contention of local farmers, saying once the ban on newly purchased agricultural land is lifted, the land itself would become a gambling chip used by giant corporate conglomerates.
"The price of Taiwan's agricultural land has long occupied the No.1 spot worldwide. Once we loosen restrictions over agricultural land use, it might create short-term advantages. But in the long term, once land supply exceeds market needs, prices will drop dramatically," said Lin Kuo-ching (
"I agreed with Peng's stance. Agricultural land can preserve the nation's ecology. However, I would beg people not to ignore the problems of framers while serving themselves."
"If everyone wants to live happily, then everyone has to pay the price," he said.
Chen Chi-nan (陳其南), the dean of Humanities and Social Sciences at National Chiao Tung University, also said a balance is needed between national and regional interests.
"On the one hand, the farming industry and agricultural land is a national heritage, and also an asset for future generations. But on the other hand, the livelihood and interests of farmers who live and look after the land on our behalf need to be shared by all citizens,'' Chen said.
The Thai government on Friday announced that Taiwanese would be allowed to stay in the country for up to 60 days per entry, under the Southeast Asian country’s visa-free program starting from today. Taiwan is among 93 countries included in the Thai visa-waiver program, which has been expanded from 57 countries, with the visa-exempt entry extended from 30 to 60 days. After taking office last year, Thai Prime Minister Srettha Thavisin has vowed to grant more visa waivers to foreign travelers as part of efforts to stimulate tourism. The expanded visa-waiver program was on Friday signed by Thai Minister of the Interior Anutin
BAIL APPEALS: The former vice premier was ordered to be held incommunicado despite twice being granted bail and paying a total of NT$12 million in bond The Taoyuan District Court yesterday ordered the detention of former vice premier Cheng Wen-tsan (鄭文燦), who is being investigated for alleged corruption while serving as Taoyuan mayor from December 2014 to December 2022, and that he be held incommunicado. The court made the ruling during a bail hearing after prosecutors appealed its bail ruling twice. Cheng on Saturday was released after posting bail of NT$5 million (US$153,818). However, after prosecutors lodged an appeal, the High Court on Monday revoked the original ruling and ordered the Taoyuan District Court to hold another bail hearing. On Tuesday, the district court granted bail to Cheng a second
PEACE AND SECURITY: China’s military ambitions present ‘the greatest strategic challenge to Japan and the world, Japan’s annual defense white paper said yesterday Japan yesterday warned that China risked escalating tensions with Taiwan with an increase in military exercises that appeared aimed in part at readying Beijing’s forces for a possible invasion. Japan’s annual assessment of security threats, including those posed by China, North Korea and Russia, comes as Taiwan closely monitors Chinese People’s Liberation Army air and sea exercises, including one with the Shandong aircraft carrier in the Pacific Ocean. The drills are the latest in a series including maneuvers in the Taiwan Strait last year that a senior US general said would be key to any invasion. “Because of that increase in military activity,
HAN KUANG: The exercises, which are to run from July 22 to 26, will feature unscripted war games and a decentralized command and control structure, military officers said The armed forces would for the first time test new rules of engagement (ROE) at this month’s annual Han Kuang exercises, the Ministry of National Defense (MND) said yesterday. The exercises, which are to run from July 22 to 26, will feature unscripted war games, and a decentralized command and control structure, military officers told a news conference in Taipei. ROE cards would be issued to select combat troops to test their ability to function without tight control, they said. The most recent edition of the rules was published last year, they said. One of the cards’ two templates identifies enemy targets that soldiers