While the central government draws up a blueprint to rebuild disaster areas following the 921 earthquake, grassroots involvement -- with an emphasis on a "bottom-up" decision-making process that would conform to diverse local demands -- could make the rebuilding process more feasible, critics said yesterday.
Experts involved in relief efforts in central Taiwan said the central government should limit its intervention in rebuilding quake-stricken areas to restoration of public construction or other similar efforts, adding that more room should be left for local communities to decide for themselves exactly what needs to be done.
Chen Chi-nan (
"The central government may come up with ideas to rebuild townships from scratch, as if nobody actually lives there. Such ideas are fostered by both bureaucrats and intellectuals," Chen said.
"But the reality is there are people living in these areas, with their attachments to their homes as well as their properties located there," he said.
"So that's why we decided to communicate with people in local communities, trying to evaluate the whole situation from the bottom-up angle," he added.
"Only by doing so, can we match the demand in disaster areas and the supply needed," he said.
Chen and his team went to Nantou County immediately following the earthquake on Sept. 21, engaging in rescue and relief efforts while also inviting locals to discuss their visions of reconstruction.
Chunghsing Community (
It was perhaps the first local community in a disaster area to set up a community reconstruction committee with an aim to gain more control over the rebuilding process, Chen said.
"They had previously been talking about the need to set up public space that was lacking in the past, such as parking lots. These are problems akin to individuals [residing] there. How can that be envisioned by the central government through a top-down decision making process?" Chen asked.
Economist Chen Po-chih (陳博志), from National Taiwan University, echoed Chen's view. He said the government's rebuilding blueprints should be "practical," taking into account various regional concerns.
"The government should not intervene too much, and it should allow local citizens to take part in planning what to do [in the rebuilding process]," he said.
Moreover, Chen Chi-nan said the scheme was also to help quake victims in disaster areas to stand on their own feet.
Instead of waiting passively for the government to solve their problems, local people can cultivate a sense of empowerment and learn how to take responsibility for the development of their own community, Chen said.
While the media coverage of calamities faced by people in the disaster-stricken areas have diminished over time, Chen said, "the real pain they face is only about to begin. For the past two weeks, many simply sat waiting for another round of huge aftershocks."
"But after one month or so, they may expect to see their dislocated social network to be back to normal, but then they will realize it's merely wishful thinking," Chen added.
Wu Yin-chang (
One of the major steps taken by Chen's team so far has been to publish a newsletter titled Reconstruction of Hometowns (
The publication was inspired by a similar phenomenon following the 1995 Kobe quake in Japan, he said.
Less than one month after the quake, community newspapers appeared in various disaster areas in Japan, he said.
"Communication among various disaster areas can help people there maintain confidence throughout the rebuilding process. Or else they'll feel frustrated, passively waiting for assistance from outside," Chen said.
CIVILIAN SIGHTING: Fishers from Penghu County took a photograph of a Chinese guided-missile destroyer near the median line of the Taiwan Strait China sent 77 military aircraft around Taiwan over a two-day period ending yesterday morning, an uptick in its activity over the past few weeks. Forty-one Chinese military aircraft were detected in the vicinity of Taiwan in the 24-hour period that ended at 6am yesterday, with 23 crossing the median line of the Taiwan Strait and nine crossing its extension, entering the country’s northern, southwestern and eastern air defense identification zones (ADIZs), flight routes released yesterday by the Ministry of National Defense showed. Of the nine aircraft that crossed the median line’s extension, were seven fighter jets and two drones that flew around
ESCALATING TENSIONS: The US called for restraint and meaningful dialogue after Beijing threatened Taiwanese independence advocates with the death sentence The US on Monday condemned China’s “escalatory and destabilizing language and actions” toward Taiwan after Beijing last week announced new guidelines to punish supporters of Taiwanese independence. Asked about the guidelines, which included the death sentence for “diehard” independence advocates, US Department of State spokesman Matthew Miller said: “We strongly condemn the escalatory and destabilizing language and actions from PRC [People’s Republic of China] officials.” “We continue to urge restraint and no unilateral change to the status quo,” he said at the press briefing. The US urges China to “engage in meaningful dialogue with Taiwan,” Miller said, adding that “threats and legal
UNDER THE RADAR: Two US deputy assistant state secretaries visited Taiwan and met with foreign diplomats to discuss how to boost the nation’s international participation US officials who visited Taiwan earlier this week met with foreign representatives and told them that UN Resolution 2758 does not involve Taiwan nor should it be conflated with China’s “one China” principle, sources said yesterday. UN Resolution 2758 recognized the People’s Republic of China as the sole legitimate government of China in 1971. Beijing has been misrepresenting it to exclude Taiwan from the international organization and its affiliates. A representative to Taiwan, requesting anonymity, quoted the US officials as saying during a meeting that as long as it is not specified in UN Resolution 2758, “everything is feasible” with regard to
‘SEPARATIST’ CRACKDOWN: Beijing’s actions would only sow discord on both sides of the Taiwan Strait and damage exchanges, the Mainland Affairs Council said China has no jurisdiction over Taiwan, and its so-called laws and norms have no binding force on Taiwanese, the Mainland Affairs Council (MAC) said yesterday as it called on Taiwanese “not to be threatened and intimidated” by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). The council issued the remarks after China earlier in the day threatened to impose the death penalty in extreme cases of what it called “diehard Taiwanese independence separatists.” China’s state-run Xinhua news agency yesterday said the Chinese government unveiled guidelines that say its courts, prosecutors, public and state security bodies should “severely punish Taiwanese independence diehards for splitting the country