The terms extensions of the National Assembly and the Legislative Yuan may have become law when President Lee Teng-hui's (李登輝) promulgated this year's constitutional amendments on Sept. 15 -- but the furor over the extensions shows no signs of dying down.
The KMT's expulsion of National Assembly Speaker Su Nan-cheng (蘇南成) from the party -- and therefore also from his post -- on Sept. 8, made him the scapegoat for the affair, but has done little to calm the uproar.
Meanwhile, the DPP's assembly caucus leaders -- who worked with their KMT counterparts to get the extensions passed -- continue to claim the package was the maximum reform effort possible, given the current political climate.
PHOTO: TAIPEI TIMES
Critics, however, say that it is too early to determine whether the term extension amendment will prove to be good medicine or poison for the congressional reform effort.
Under the amendment, the length of the current National Assembly term was extended by two years and 48 days to June 2002; the voting process for the next assembly election was changed to a proportional system, in which seats will be divided up according to the ratio of votes each party gains in that year's legislative elections; and the number of deputies was reduced from the current 316 to 150. The next legislative elections were also postponed from December 2001 to June 2002.
The deputies passed the amendment despite strong objections from both the DPP and the KMT party headquarters, as well as a lack of public support.
DPP assembly caucus leader Liu I-deh (
"Even though we want to perform a surgical operation to remove the `political appendix,' we have to first give it an anesthetic injection,'' he said, referring to the DPP's long-standing view of the National Assembly as an unnecessary institution.
"In using a `sweetener' [of term extensions] to lure the support of deputies in exchange for a proportional representation system, such a deal could not be more profitable," he said.
"My proposal aimed to abolish the assembly by means of suicide," Liu added.
Others such as Wu Nan-jen (吳乃仁), a member of the DPP's Central Standing Committee, echoed Liu's belief.
"Even though we cannot abolish the assembly in the short term, a proportional system can help prevent the situation from getting any worse. If we continue to hold assembly elections, I can guarantee that the quality of deputies will continue to decline," Wu said.
"I would rather chain the monster-like assembly with a proportional system than allows unrestrained elected deputies to amend the constitution however they like," he added.
Some academics dismiss the "reform" vocabulary, saying there is nothing to guarantee such reform aims will be acted upon. Or, as one scholar put it, the "reform cloak has become no more than a `final refuge' for political scoundrels.''
Beyond the actual reform considerations, however, deputies from both the DPP and the KMT admit that if they failed to cooperate to pass the controversial amendments with the required three-fourths majority (as happened in the previous assembly session), they would have run into more difficulties in the new session.
"In a newly-elected assembly next March [if there had been no extension] there would likely have been more than 100 deputies supporting KMT maverick presidential candidate James Soong (
But critics said the term extension package not only violated the deputies' basic mandate with the electorate, but is bound to have a negative influence on their motives.
"The ends can never justified the means -- and the ends are almost unreachable," said Nan Fang Shou, a prominent political critic.
"A fixed term length is the fundamental principle of democracy. No other reason could overthrow that basic rule of the game. So how could the deputies extend their terms by more than two years without asking the permission of voters them-selves?" he added.
Other academics expressed doubts over the blueprint for the assembly's future drawn up by the two parties' delegates, saying that although the assembly will now be chosen by proportional representation, that in itself will not necessary result in the abolition of the assembly.
"The only thing I can see the term extension doing is merely changing the electoral approach of deputies -- the authority of the deputies' offices still remains unchanged. And we have to wait at least six years to evaluate the effects of the new arrangements, so at this point there are few clues as to how to actually abolish the assembly," said Chen Shin-min (
Hu Fu (胡佛), a renowned constitutional expert from National Taiwan University, pointed out that even if the assembly adopts a totally proportional system, that in itself can do little to fix the assembly's institutional problems, and could in fact add to them.
"Imagine if there is no re-election pressure. The assembly could end up becoming a stage for the three major parties to put pressure on their own deputies, make their own demands, then dividing the spoils among themselves," Hu said.
Scholars say there are other possible contradictions that would come with a proportional system, including the rationalization of the "division of labor" between the as-sembly and the legislature.
The assembly's current exclusive powers, for example, include both confirmation of senior governmental officials and amending the constitution.
"It would be rather odd to see constitutional amendments proposed by the legislature still having to earn the approval from assembly deputies -- who are themselves chosen as a result of the election of lawmakers," Chen said.
Furthermore, analysts stressed, the Constitution is an "end value" by itself, not a tool for political infighting.
"The Constitution is a fundamental law, not candy. How can we use it to serve another purpose?" Hu asked.
Basically, Hu said, a legal framework by itself is never enough to bring out mature democratic politics. He cited the example of the recently introduced proportional system, saying once it is transplanted to Taiwan, it will forever change the island's political landscape.
"The law by itself is never enough," Hu said. "Taiwan has implemented reforms since 1990, but the more reform we introduced, the more we actually backpedaled, and neither the parties nor the public have been able to identify the proper criteria for developing democracy."
Critics such as Nan said nobody can deny achieving reform carries a price, and that the core of the issue will be how high the price is and how long will it take.
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs yesterday condemned incidents in which signage supporting Taiwan was snatched from spectators watching badminton at the Paris Olympics, saying it contravened the spirit of the Games and freedom of speech. The incident took place during the men’s doubles match on Friday, when Taiwan’s Lee Yang (李洋) and Wang Chi-lin (王齊麟) advanced to the final after beating Denmark’s Kim Astrup and Anders Skaarup Rasmussen. A unidentified man in a pink shirt was seen seizing the sign from a female spectator — later identified as Yang Chih-yun (楊芷芸), a Taiwanese studying in France — before being removed from the
TALLY: Sharpshooter Lee Meng-yuan won Taiwan’s first medal in Paris, taking home a bronze, while boxer Chen Nien-chin has secured at least a bronze medal Taiwanese badminton duo Lee Yang (李洋) and Wang Chi-lin (王齊麟) yesterday won the gold medal in the men's doubles final at the Paris Olympics, defeating China's Liang Weikeng (梁偉鏗) and Wang Chan (王昶). The victory made them the first Taiwanese shuttlers to win more than one Olympic medal with back-to-back gold. They were crowned champions in the event at the Tokyo Olympics three years ago. Earlier in the day, Taiwanese boxer Lin Yu-ting (林郁婷) secured her first Olympic medal in front of a crowd chanting her name, a day after fellow boxer Imane Khelif did the same, following days of online abuse
Taiwan is to secure at least one medal at the Paris Olympics following boxer Wu Shih-yi’s (吳詩儀) quarter-final victory in the women’s 60kg (lightweight) division, while the nation’s male badminton players topped their groups. Wu defeated Maria Jose Palacios of Ecuador, a Pan American Games bronze medalist last year, by majority decision, with four out of five judges scoring in her favor. The 26-year-old pugilist is guaranteed to win at least a bronze medal, as there is no bronze-medal match in boxing. The victory was significant for Taiwan. Wu’s success came after the elimination of three Taiwanese boxers, including Kan Chia-wei (甘佳葳) in the
A hacking group believed to be linked to the Chinese government stole passwords and documents from a Taiwanese government-affiliated research center that specializes in computing, cybersecurity researchers at Cisco Systems Inc said on Thursday. The attackers used a kind of malicious software tool that is almost entirely used by China-based groups, after they gained access to the unnamed research center as early as July last year, Cisco’s Talos threat intelligence group said in a report shared exclusively with Bloomberg News. Based on that and other techniques, Cisco believes with “moderate confidence” that the hackers are part of a state-sponsored espionage group called