Taiwan's presidential race had already been gathering steam even before last year's September earthquake, with public opinion polls showing independent candidate James Soong (
At that time, a friend from Taipei told me that the "dump-save" effect would kick in if Lien's popularity failed to increase by December. Therefore, I was full of curiosity about how the campaign would develop even before my visit to Taipei that month.
The few days of my short visit coincided with several major news events, the most shocking of which was the James Soong financial scandal.
Illustration: Mountain People
On Dec. 9, KMT legislator Yang Chi-hsiung (
Soong's hasty response aggravated public dissatisfaction and sent his popularity ratings into a nosedive, plummeting from more than 30 percent to 24 percent within three days. During those dramatic days, I got a glimpse of how Taiwanese democracy actually works through my conversations with various people, including members of the media.
The revelations were a turning point in the presidential race, eliminating Soong's lead and making for a close race between three major candidates: Soong, Chen Shui-bian (
In whose hands is the presidency going to fall?As far as I understand it, the overwhelming response has been that Soong has lost his chance and now he is hardly able to hold his ground against the massive KMT onslaught. Nevertheless, there are still many variables and no one can predict the outcome. However, issues concerning election culture and political trends are worth discussing.
There have been many wars of words centering on "money and sex" since John Chang (
Take the Soong scandal as an example. Many pro-Soong people have demanded Soong come clean. While expressing suspicion about Yang's methods in acquiring information on the scandal, they have also shown respect for the facts that have emerged. The editor in chief of a monthly journal told me: "Of course, these attacks, the dirt they dig up, and the neglect of important national issues are all inevitable. But the electorate is fortunate in getting to know the candidates better." Some reporters said, "that political figures have to undergo all kinds of tests and challenges all the time is proof enough that Taiwan's politics is moving toward democracy. No one can hold power behind a dark curtain."
It is easy to use the word "mudslinging" about political conflicts, but who would dare to sling mud if there is no guarantee of civil rights, or if a free press does not exist? Over the past 20 years since Deng Xiaoping (
Putting the personal integrity of state leaders under the spotlight is a sign of the transparency and openness of Taiwan's democracy. The more thoroughly they are exposed, the more evident is Taiwan's self-confidence in its own system, the more it can distinguish itself from the totalitarian systems where power struggles go on behind black curtains.
One saying currently popular among the Taiwanese is "choose the least rotten apple from the barrel." The statement sounds like an expression of impotence, but at least it is practical. Everyone knows that politicians are human and cannot be models of perfection, one can only face reality and seek gradual improvement.
I also heard different opinions in Taipei over the issue of cruelty. One opinion is that Taiwan is a society under the rule of law, but threats of legal action made during election campaigns are often left unsettled once the elections are over. Even if someone takes an issue to court, there are laws on which proceedings can be based. There will be no indiscriminate denunciations as under authoritarian regimes, nor will the power of political parties replace the rule of law.
Even if Soong loses the election, he will not be persecuted mercilessly. Also, contrary to what some say, Soong will not undertake a reckoning with Lee Teng-hui (李登輝) if elected. Of course, after liberalizing its politics, Taiwan will continue to witness power struggles, but it will be spared the sight of illegal persecution.
Another opinion is that anyone who wants to enter the kitchen should not fear the heat. Those vying for the nation's highest authority and the power to dictate the fate of millions of people should have courage and be prepared to pay the price.
There is also another explanation for the personal integrity of candidates becoming a campaign focus. The Taiwanese call the war of words between candidates the "saliva war" (
There are perhaps two causes for this:
One is that, despite all the abuse the candidates are heaping on each other, people already have a fairly good understanding of their candidates after watching their performance over so many years. Even though some accuse Soong of planning to sell out Taiwan or receiving Chinese funds, everyone is also aware of Soong's "anti-communist" stance. One pro-Soong friend told me: "We support Soong because he has a strong character necessary to tackle the Communist party. Lien Chan is too soft."
Also, even though many criticize Chen Shui-bian for championing Taiwan independence, everyone also knows whose votes he is working to get. One of his three major promises has been that there will be no war in the Taiwan Strait. Therefore, we can assume that he will not actually promote Taiwan independence if elected.
Another opinion is that Lee remains a strong factor in Taiwan politics in what scholars call the "post-Lee era." In the area of cross-strait relations, for example, Soong has not dared to openly oppose Lee's "state-to-state" model. Lien, Soong and Chen are all softer than Lee in their China policies. Therefore, relations across the Taiwan Strait cannot possibly deteriorate after the election.
It was good that Soong's popularity ratings fell after his financial scandal, preventing Lee and Chen from resorting to more radical cross-strait policies, one writer told me.
What he said might not be correct, but it does reflect lingering fears among Taiwanese from China's military threat in the run up to the previous presidential election.
Soong's setback has given Chen's camp a chance to talk up its "anti-black gold" policy. Now, as seen on TV, Soong's expression is rather gloomy, while Lien appears the same "naturally decent" man as described by Hau Pei-tsun (
In other words, because of Lee's influence, policy differences between candidates no longer need to be as clearly differentiated. As Taiwan society integrates itself into a gemeinschaft (
Jin Zhong (金鐘) is editor in chief of the Hong Kong-based Open Magazine.
TYPHOON: The storm’s path indicates a high possibility of Krathon making landfall in Pingtung County, depending on when the storm turns north, the CWA said Typhoon Krathon is strengthening and is more likely to make landfall in Taiwan, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said in a forecast released yesterday afternoon. As of 2pm yesterday, the CWA’s updated sea warning for Krathon showed that the storm was about 430km southeast of Oluanpi (鵝鑾鼻), Taiwan’s southernmost point. It was moving in west-northwest at 9kph, with maximum sustained winds of 119kph and gusts of up to 155kph, CWA data showed. Krathon is expected to move further west before turning north tomorrow, CWA forecaster Wu Wan-hua (伍婉華) said. The CWA’s latest forecast and other countries’ projections of the storm’s path indicate a higher
SECURITY: The New Zealand and Australian navies also sailed military vessels through the Strait yesterday to assert the right of freedom of navigation The Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force on Wednesday made its first-ever transit through the Taiwan Strait in response to the intrusion by a Chinese reconnaissance aircraft into Japan’s sovereign airspace last month, Yomiuri Shimbun reported yesterday. The Japanese news platform reported that the destroyer JS Sazanamisailed down through the Taiwan Strait on Wednesday, citing sources in the Japanese government with knowledge of the matter. Japanese Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshimasa Hayashi declined to comment on the reports at a regular briefing because they concern military operations. Military vessels from New Zealand and Australia also sailed through the Strait on the same day, Wellington’s defense ministry
The Central Weather Administration (CWA) is set to issue sea and land warnings for Tropical Storm Krathon as projections showed that the tropical storm could strengthen into a typhoon as it approaches Taiwan proper, the CWA said yesterday. The sea warning is scheduled to take effect this morning and the land warning this evening, it said. The storm formed yesterday morning and in the evening reached a point 620 nautical miles (1,148km) southeast of Oluanpi (鵝鑾鼻), Taiwan proper’s southernmost point, moving west-southwest at 4 kph as it strengthened, the CWA said. Its radius measured between 220km and 250km, it added. Krathon is projected
SOVEREIGNTY EMPHASIZED: President William Lai said that Taiwan ‘absolutely will not sign’ an agreement with Beijing implying that the nation is part of China Taiwan hopes to join like-minded nations under the democratic umbrella and jointly counter authoritarian aggression, President William Lai (賴清德) said in a prerecorded speech during the annual Concordia Summit in New York on Tuesday. Lai addressed the summit via video at Concordia’s invitation, using the opportunity to speak on the issue of Chinese aggression toward Taiwan and Beijing’s distortion of UN Resolution 2758. Lai’s comments came on the heels of the 79th session of the UN General Assembly, which opened on Tuesday. China has “distorted” UN Resolution 2758 “in support of its ‘one China’ principle,” he said. Through its misinterpretation