The alleged forced hospitalization by the Taipei City Government of a homeless man on Thursday drew criticism yesterday, with groups saying moves to increase monitoring of people with mental illness could be a breach of privacy rights and could discourage them from seeking treatment.
A man surnamed Ting (丁), nicknamed “Wobble-wobble Man” (搖搖哥) for his distinctive gait by students of National Chengchi University, where he is often seen, was shown being forced into an ambulance in video footage posted online on Thursday.
“Even if he has a mental illness, if there is no concern that he will harm himself or others, he should not be consigned to hospital,” Taiwan Association for Human Rights deputy chairman Weng Kuo-yan (翁國彥) said.
Photo: Liao Chen-huei, Taipei Times
“He was known to students for years and never sought to do anything that would harm anyone,” Weng said, adding that the association was seeking a judicial review to overturn the city’s decision, which he said breached the Mental Health Act (精神衛生法).
Any loosening of regulations governing forced hospitalization should be ruled out given the government’s abuse of its existing powers, Weng said.
Loosened regulations have been proposed following the beheading of a four-year-old girl in Taipei’s Neihu District (內湖) on Monday, with the city government claiming that suspect Wang Ching-yu (王景玉) has a mental illness.
Wang was reportedly escorted to the emergency room of Taipei City Hospital’s Songde Branch by police in 2014 after a fight with his parents, but chose to ignore hospital recommendations that he remain under observation.
“When there are not adequate resources to care for patients, big moves [to forcibly hospitalize patients] will just lead to the exhaustion of the entire system,” said Wu Yi-cheng (吳易澄), head of Mackay Memorial Hospital’s department of psychiatry and an executive committee member of the Taiwan Association for Human Rights.
The city government’s objective should be to increase the number of personnel available to help mentally ill people participate in society, Wu said, adding that violent lashing out on the part of a mentally ill person is often the result of suffering, exclusion and other “social violence.”
In response to the controversy concerning Ting, Taipei City Government spokesman Sidney Lin (林鶴明) said Thursday’s move was meant to help Ting, adding that the city stepped in at the request of security guards at the university.
The Taipei Department of Health said it hospitalized Ting out of concern over his deteriorating ability to take care of himself and his health, adding that it appeared Ting had not eaten for days.
The department said it received a report about Ting from residents in February, but had been unable to locate him, adding that he was on a list of people it routinely checks on.
It contacted the police to “reason with” Ting so he could be hospitalized, the department said, adding that Ting consented to being hospitalized at Songde hospital.
Police on the scene on Thursdasy might have caused misunderstanding among people who witnessed the incident, the department said.
At a hearing at the Taipei District Court later yesterday, Ting asked via a teleconference that he be discharged from the hospital.
While the hospital said it would respect Ting’s wishes, the court is to make a ruling today on whether Ting should be discharged.
Separately, groups expressed concern over reports that government agencies would seek to increase monitoring of mentally ill people.
Eva Teng (滕西華), secretary-general of the Taiwan Association for Psychosocial Rehabilitation, said her organization had received numerous reports from hospitals and the Ministry of Health and Welfare that other government agencies were seeking to gain access to lists of people seeking medical treatment for mental illness, which would be a breach of privacy rights.
Teng said that by allowing Wang’s medical history to be published, the city government showed its disregard for privacy laws.
“Whether the suspect is even mentally impaired is still undetermined, but the city has already made up its mind,” she said.
Democratic Progressive Party Legislator Wang Jung-chang (王榮璋) said allowing mental illness records to be shared among government agencies would cause people to be less willing to seek treatment.
“People will worry that next time there is a commotion, they will be suspected or receive ‘special attention’ from government agencies,” he said.
As eight basketball-playing international students appealed to the Taiwanese basketball industry after they were excluded from the draft of an upcoming new league merging the P.League+ and the T1 League, the new league’s preparatory committee spokesperson Chang Shu-jen (張樹人) yesterday said the committee would tomorrow discuss the supplementary measures and whether the international students can join the draft. The students on Tuesday called for support on their right to play in the upcoming new league, after a merger involving the two leagues impacted their eligibility for the draft. The international players from the University Basketball Association (UBA), led by first pick prospect
Some foreign companies are considering moving Taiwanese employees out of China after Beijing said it could impose the death penalty on “die-hard” Taiwanese independence advocates, four people familiar with the matter said. The new guidelines have caused some Taiwanese expatriates and foreign multinationals operating in China to scramble to assess their legal risks and exposure, said the people, who include a lawyer and two executives with direct knowledge of the discussions. “Several companies have come to us to assess the risks to their personnel,” said the lawyer, James Zimmerman, a Beijing-based partner at the Perkins Coie law firm. He declined to identify
WARNING: China has stepped up harassment of foreign vessels after its new regulation took effect last month, an official said, citing an incident in the Diaoyutai Islands The Coast Guard Administration (CGA) yesterday linked China’s seizure of a Taiwanese fishing vessel illegally operating in its territorial waters to Beijing’s new regulation authorizing the China Coast Guard to seize boats in waters it claims. Chinese officials boarded and then seized a Taiwanese fishing vessel operating near China’s coast close to Kinmen County late on Tuesday and took it to a Chinese port, the CGA said. The Penghu-registered squid fishing vessel Da Jin Man No. 88 (大進滿88) was boarded and seized by China Coast Guard east-northeast of Liaoluo Bay (料羅灣), 17.5 nautical miles (32.4km) from Taiwan’s restricted waters off Kinmen,
NOT ENOUGH: Although the US is to deliver Switchblade 300s and Altius 600M-Vs to Taiwan, military leaders believe the nation needs more attack drones, a source said The Ministry of National Defense (MND) has included the funding needed to mass-produce Type-1 and Type-2 suicide drones in next year’s budget plan, a military source said yesterday. Although the US government last month approved sales of Switchblade 300 loitering munitions and Altius 600M-V uncrewed aerial vehicles to Taiwan, which are scheduled for delivery between this year and the next, military leaders assessed that Taiwan would still have an inadequate number of attack drones to bolster national defense, the source said, asking to remain anonymous. Taiwan needs to mass produce locally made attack drones, including Type-1 and Type-2 suicide drones, they