While President Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) has reiterated that the so-called “1992 consensus” was reached by Taiwan and China in 1992 to the effect that each side recognizes “one China, with each side having its own interpretation,” US cables recently released by WikiLeaks show that Chinese officials and academics clearly have a different understanding on what constitutes the “consensus.”
Both the Ma administration and China have stated that the consensus has been and should remain the foundation of cross-strait relations and dialogue.
In a cable dated Dec. 11, 2007, then-Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) presidential candidate Ma told visiting American Institute in Taiwan Chairman Raymond Burghardt that the “one China, different interpretations” rubric of the consensus would be the key to any dialogue with China, adding that the KMT would reassure Beijing that its interpretation of the consensus is “steadfastly opposed to [Taiwan] independence.”
As recently as a press conference on Aug. 28, Ma said that despite the fact that no concrete results were reached during the cross-strait negotiations in 1992, both sides agreed that each side could have its own interpretation of “one China,” adding that while the term “1992 consensus” was indeed coined later, the idea of “one China, with each side having its own interpretation” did exist.
However, according to a leaked US cable dated Dec. 24, 2008, Taiwan Affairs Office Minister Wang Yi (王毅) mentioned “different interpretations” when the Chinese official discussed cross-strait relations with then-US ambassador to China Clark Randt.
“Both sides now accept and recognize the 1992 consensus, which means that both sides essentially accept there is only one China,” Wang was quoted as telling Randt, adding that in order “to solve [Taiwan’s] international space problem, the two sides must stick to the one China framework, because the improvement in cross-strait relations thus far has been on the basis of the one China principle.”
The international community accepts the “one China consensus” and UN-affiliated organizations also legally accept one China, therefore on the international stage “the rules are set and [they] cannot be changed,” Wang was quoted by the cable as saying.
Chinese academics expressed similar views in another cable dated March 21, 2008, issued by the US embassy in Beijing.
Zhou Zhihuai (周志懷), vice president of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences’ Institute of Taiwan Studies, was quoted in the cable as saying that the consensus is flawed because “there is too much wiggle room for interpretation and because the Taiwan position of ‘each with its own interpretation’ is tantamount to [an] acceptance of two Chinas.”
While both sides want to improve relations, Zhou said, neither side has much room to make concessions.
The cable also quoted Sun Shengliang (孫盛良), director of the same institute’s economics department, as saying the “consensus was basically invented by KMT scholar Su Chi (蘇起).”
The cable showed Randt making a side note that it was the first time his embassy had heard the Chinese acknowledge this point.
In a recent forum held in Taipei, Taiwanese academics highlighted the different views on the “1992 consensus” held by officials in Taipei and Beijing, with Lo Chih-cheng (羅致政), a political scientist at Soochow University, saying: “China never talks about the 1992 consensus without mentioning its opposition to Taiwan independence.”
Tung Cheng-yuan (童振源), a professor at National Chengchi University said at the same forum that the real consensus between the Ma administration and Beijing was a “recognition of the one China principle” and “opposition to Taiwan independence.”
BAIL APPEALS: The former vice premier was ordered to be held incommunicado despite twice being granted bail and paying a total of NT$12 million in bond The Taoyuan District Court yesterday ordered the detention of former vice premier Cheng Wen-tsan (鄭文燦), who is being investigated for alleged corruption while serving as Taoyuan mayor from December 2014 to December 2022, and that he be held incommunicado. The court made the ruling during a bail hearing after prosecutors appealed its bail ruling twice. Cheng on Saturday was released after posting bail of NT$5 million (US$153,818). However, after prosecutors lodged an appeal, the High Court on Monday revoked the original ruling and ordered the Taoyuan District Court to hold another bail hearing. On Tuesday, the district court granted bail to Cheng a second
The Thai government on Friday announced that Taiwanese would be allowed to stay in the country for up to 60 days per entry, under the Southeast Asian country’s visa-free program starting from today. Taiwan is among 93 countries included in the Thai visa-waiver program, which has been expanded from 57 countries, with the visa-exempt entry extended from 30 to 60 days. After taking office last year, Thai Prime Minister Srettha Thavisin has vowed to grant more visa waivers to foreign travelers as part of efforts to stimulate tourism. The expanded visa-waiver program was on Friday signed by Thai Minister of the Interior Anutin
PEACE AND SECURITY: China’s military ambitions present ‘the greatest strategic challenge to Japan and the world, Japan’s annual defense white paper said yesterday Japan yesterday warned that China risked escalating tensions with Taiwan with an increase in military exercises that appeared aimed in part at readying Beijing’s forces for a possible invasion. Japan’s annual assessment of security threats, including those posed by China, North Korea and Russia, comes as Taiwan closely monitors Chinese People’s Liberation Army air and sea exercises, including one with the Shandong aircraft carrier in the Pacific Ocean. The drills are the latest in a series including maneuvers in the Taiwan Strait last year that a senior US general said would be key to any invasion. “Because of that increase in military activity,
HAN KUANG: The exercises, which are to run from July 22 to 26, will feature unscripted war games and a decentralized command and control structure, military officers said The armed forces would for the first time test new rules of engagement (ROE) at this month’s annual Han Kuang exercises, the Ministry of National Defense (MND) said yesterday. The exercises, which are to run from July 22 to 26, will feature unscripted war games, and a decentralized command and control structure, military officers told a news conference in Taipei. ROE cards would be issued to select combat troops to test their ability to function without tight control, they said. The most recent edition of the rules was published last year, they said. One of the cards’ two templates identifies enemy targets that soldiers