Former Council of Agriculture minister Lee Chin-lung (李金龍) yesterday accused the authorities of reacting too slowly to the recent outbreak of bird flu in Kaohsiung County’s Luchu Township (路竹).
“Although I have no evidence, it looks very strange and my instinct is that [information pertaining to this case] was not made transparent,” he said.
“What the law says is one thing: People have a right to know about an epidemic as soon as it is confirmed,” Lee said.
Although the council said lab results had only been confirmed yesterday, Lee said: “Some experts are saying the council reacted a bit too slowly. I am of a similar opinion.”
Responding to a statement by the council that to ensure the validity of the results it had conducted two separate viral separation and cultivation tests, Lee said: “If it had been an epidemic, we would have faced dire consequences within those two months.”
“I’m not saying you cannot do the analysis twice, but it is very rarely seen,” Lee said.
Responding to comments by Animal Health Research Institute (AHRI) deputy director Lee Shu-hui (李淑慧) that the test was a complex process that required between 19 and 40 days, Lee said: “She is saying that to [reporters] because [viral analysis] is not their expertise. This is like going [from Taipei] to Kaohsiung. While you could have taken the high-speed rail, you decided to bike there.”
“Epidemic prevention is war — you have to employ the fastest and most accurate way to confirm an infection,” Lee said.
While viral cultivation, which yields an Intravenous Pathogenicity Index such as the one AHRI obtained, was an option, Lee said that RNA sequencing, which can also confirm a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) test, would take about 10 days.
At a press conference on Saturday, the council said an expert panel had confirmed an outbreak of a low-pathogenic strain of the bird flu virus H5N2 at a chicken farm in Kaohsiung County.
As fears of an outbreak arose on Oct. 21, the council said that while it was analyzing samples from the farm it also launched a epidemic prevention mechanism.
After a bird sample tested positive in a PCR test, which takes one or two days, in October, Lee Shu-hui said her team conducted two consecutive confirmational analyses — the first based on samples collected on Oct. 21 and the second on samples collected on Nov. 12 — to confirm the infection.
“Our first result on Nov. 12 showed what looked like a high-pathogenic strain of H5N2, but as less than 3 percent of chickens died, the reality did not agree with the lab test,” she said.
Aware of the potential for an epidemic, the council ordered a second examination while taking precautionary measures to avoid creating public fear, she said.
However, some experts have questioned the council’s handling of the crisis and raised doubts about transparency.
Earlier last week, former chairman of the interministry avian and pandemic influenza control committee Chen Chien-jen (陳建仁), now at Academia Sinica, said that regardless of whether Taiwan had an epidemic or not, the council should have make the information available to minimize public fears.
“If the government had done [everything it could to prevent an epidemic], it should have let people know and informed them that the case was closed,” Chen said.
Meanwhile, Control Yuan member Cheng Jen-hung (程仁宏) said yesterday he would launch a probe into whether the council failed in its duties during the outbreak.
“I will examine the procedure and time the council took [in responding to the outbreak], whether it had a sound supervision mechanism and whether it kept information transparent and [did all it could] to protect chicken farmers and consumers,” Cheng said when asked for comment.
Cheng said he would request information from the council today.
Meanwhile, the COA last night issued a short press release saying that it welcomed any bird flu experts to read over its analysis of the outbreak.
The COA said it was willing to discuss the analysis with other experts.
A magnitude 6.4 earthquake and several aftershocks battered southern Taiwan early this morning, causing houses and roads to collapse and leaving dozens injured and 50 people isolated in their village. A total of 26 people were reported injured and sent to hospitals due to the earthquake as of late this morning, according to the latest Ministry of Health and Welfare figures. In Sising Village (西興) of Chiayi County's Dapu Township (大埔), the location of the quake's epicenter, severe damage was seen and roads entering the village were blocked, isolating about 50 villagers. Another eight people who were originally trapped inside buildings in Tainan
CLASH OF WORDS: While China’s foreign minister insisted the US play a constructive role with China, Rubio stressed Washington’s commitment to its allies in the region The Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) yesterday affirmed and welcomed US Secretary of State Marco Rubio statements expressing the US’ “serious concern over China’s coercive actions against Taiwan” and aggressive behavior in the South China Sea, in a telephone call with his Chinese counterpart. The ministry in a news release yesterday also said that the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs had stated many fallacies about Taiwan in the call. “We solemnly emphasize again that our country and the People’s Republic of China are not subordinate to each other, and it has been an objective fact for a long time, as well as
‘ARMED GROUP’: Two defendants used Chinese funds to form the ‘Republic of China Taiwan Military Government,’ posing a threat to national security, prosecutors said A retired lieutenant general has been charged after using funds from China to recruit military personnel for an “armed” group that would assist invading Chinese forces, prosecutors said yesterday. The retired officer, Kao An-kuo (高安國), was among six people indicted for contravening the National Security Act (國家安全法), the High Prosecutors’ Office said in a statement. The group visited China multiple times, separately and together, from 2018 to last year, where they met Chinese military intelligence personnel for instructions and funding “to initiate and develop organizations for China,” prosecutors said. Their actions posed a “serious threat” to “national security and social stability,” the statement
NATURAL INTERRUPTION: As cables deteriorate, core wires snap in progression along the cable, which does not happen if they are hit by an anchor, an official said Chunghwa Telecom Co (中華電信) immediately switched to a microwave backup system to maintain communications between Taiwan proper and Lienchiang County (Matsu) after two undersea cables malfunctioned due to natural deterioration, the Ministry of Digital Affairs told an emergency news conference yesterday morning. Two submarine cables connecting Taiwan proper and the outlying county — the No. 2 and No. 3 Taiwan-Matsu cables — were disconnected early yesterday morning and on Wednesday last week respectively, the nation’s largest telecom said. “After receiving the report that the No. 2 cable had failed, the ministry asked Chunghwa Telecom to immediately activate a microwave backup system, with
RSS