Last month, Taiwan’s Immigration Agency hosted this year’s International Workshop on Strategies for Combating Human Trafficking. At the same time, Human Rights for Migrant Fishers staged a protest outside the workshop, calling attention to what they say is a lack of commitment on the government’s part when it comes to protecting migrant fishermen working in Taiwan’s deep sea fleet, a group considered vulnerable to trafficking and other forms of exploitation.
From the conference and protest, some new resolutions have come forth which may or may not spark change in what has been called a deeply flawed system by long-term observers and advocates for migrant worker rights.
FUNDAMENTAL FLAWS
Photo Courtesy of the Environmental Justice Foundation
According to a report issued in March by the Fisheries Agency, there are currently 19,000 migrant workers involved in Taiwan’s fishing industry. These workers predominantly hail from Southeast Asian nations such as the Philippines and Indonesia. However, according to a 2014 report issued by the US Department of State, that number could be as high as 160,000.
The reason for the discrepancy lies in illegal practices such as transfer of crewmen from vessel to vessel at sea. Such practices can lead to migrant fishermen falling through the cracks of a system that already sees them indebted to brokers who arrange their work overseas.
Once they fall through those cracks, says Lennon Wong (汪英達), director of the Serve the People Association, indebted workers who are financially abused or otherwise exploited have little recourse but to flee their employers, a virtual impossibility if they are at sea.
Illustration: Angela Chen
“The Fishery Agency allows brokers to charge migrant fishermen a fee before they start work — creating the ideal conditions for debt bondage,” he said at the conference. “In addition, many migrant workers’ identity documents are held by the brokers or employers. They are powerless.”
Allison Lee (李麗華), Yilan Migrant Fishermen Union secretary-general, says that although the US Trafficking in Persons Report gave Taiwan a tier 1 ranking, the highest there is, for the last nine years, it has also emphasized the human rights abuse in Taiwan’s distant water fisheries in every single year’s report.
“It shows that the problem has always been there, but the government only tries to cover it up instead of really dealing with it,” Lee said.
ONGOING PROBLEM
Taiwan International Workers Association secretary-general Chen Hsiu-lien (陳秀蓮) says current labor laws dealing with Taiwan’s long-distance migrant fishermen are inadequate for their protection.
“The current regulations cannot stop human rights abuses — in fact they might even drive them,” Chen said.
Chen says migrant workers are not allowed to freely change jobs because, legally, they must receive permission from their current employer or the government.
“Some employers use this to threaten workers,” Chen said.
The power employers wield over employees in Taiwan’s fishing fleet was yet again recently brought under the international spotlight. The International Labor Organization (ILO) reported in June that the first vessel to be seized for being in violation of the Work in Fishing Convention C188 — a series of measures of protection for the world’s 38 million workers in the fishing sector that came into force in November of 2017 — was a Taiwanese ship detained in South Africa.
Inspectors who boarded the ship found a slew of problems, including migrant fishermen with a lack of work documentation, insufficient food on board and poor health and safety conditions. According to a report of the incident released by the ILO, only two of the migrant fishermen had work agreements, there was no proper listing of the ship’s crew and the ship’s anchors were not operational.
In the end, the vessel was declared unseaworthy and the crew was evacuated. Only when sufficient repairs were conducted was the ship allowed to leave port again, with a fine of about US$895 levied against the vessel’s owner.
THE WAY FORWARD
Max Schmid, deputy director of the Environmental Justice Foundation, says there are a number of things the government can do to protect the rights of migrant fishermen.
“Our number one recommendation is bringing Taiwanese law in line with the international Convention C188, such as getting rid of salary deductions, which leads to debt bondage, and trying to remove the type of conditions that lead to forced labor,” Schmid says.
Schmid was also in attendance at the International Workshop on Combating Human Trafficking in Taipei. When the question of whether or not Taiwan would adopt Convention C188 was put forth at the workshop, the answer, he found, was less than forthcoming.
“They didn’t give an answer,” he said after the workshop’s final meeting at the end of last month. “Even in Thailand, with a fleet several times the size of Taiwan’s, they will bring 188 into law in September. If a country like Thailand, with all the challenges they face in regard to human rights can do that, Taiwan should be able as well.”
In spite of this apparent lack of concrete commitment to the health and safety of migrant fishermen on behalf of the Taiwanese government, a series of resolutions were reached at week’s end. Among them, government representatives agreed to review the recruitment process for migrant fishermen, and to review as well the differences between Convention C188 and Taiwan’s Labor Standards Act, which covers the vast majority of Taiwan’s workforce, but not fishermen working in the long distance fleet.
Overall, the stated goal coming out of the workshop is to bring NGOs into an increased role in the process involved in hiring and protecting Taiwan’s deep sea migrant fishermen, according to published final remarks, with a target of eventually bringing all migrant fishermen under the protection of the Labor Standards Act (勞動基準法). However, at this time, no timetable exists for the adoption of these new stated goals.
In the meantime, says Schmid, the federal government may do well to be aware that their action, or lack thereof, could have an effect on the local fishing industry’s bottom line.
“Increasingly retailers are aware there are risks in seafood in terms of human rights abuses,” Schmid says. “We’re seeing an increasing questioning in progressive retailers and buyers. I would hope Taiwan would see this as a chance to bridge the gap in their human rights record, as they are seen as a human rights leader in the region.”
With exports of the Taiwanese fishing industry valued as high as US$2 billion, if the gap continues to exist unchecked, it could become an expensive one, as retailers come to question what the human cost of their seafood really is.
That US assistance was a model for Taiwan’s spectacular development success was early recognized by policymakers and analysts. In a report to the US Congress for the fiscal year 1962, former President John F. Kennedy noted Taiwan’s “rapid economic growth,” was “producing a substantial net gain in living.” Kennedy had a stake in Taiwan’s achievements and the US’ official development assistance (ODA) in general: In September 1961, his entreaty to make the 1960s a “decade of development,” and an accompanying proposal for dedicated legislation to this end, had been formalized by congressional passage of the Foreign Assistance Act. Two
March 31 to April 6 On May 13, 1950, National Taiwan University Hospital otolaryngologist Su You-peng (蘇友鵬) was summoned to the director’s office. He thought someone had complained about him practicing the violin at night, but when he entered the room, he knew something was terribly wrong. He saw several burly men who appeared to be government secret agents, and three other resident doctors: internist Hsu Chiang (許強), dermatologist Hu Pao-chen (胡寶珍) and ophthalmologist Hu Hsin-lin (胡鑫麟). They were handcuffed, herded onto two jeeps and taken to the Secrecy Bureau (保密局) for questioning. Su was still in his doctor’s robes at
Last week the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) said that the budget cuts voted for by the China-aligned parties in the legislature, are intended to force the DPP to hike electricity rates. The public would then blame it for the rate hike. It’s fairly clear that the first part of that is correct. Slashing the budget of state-run Taiwan Power Co (Taipower, 台電) is a move intended to cause discontent with the DPP when electricity rates go up. Taipower’s debt, NT$422.9 billion (US$12.78 billion), is one of the numerous permanent crises created by the nation’s construction-industrial state and the developmentalist mentality it
Experts say that the devastating earthquake in Myanmar on Friday was likely the strongest to hit the country in decades, with disaster modeling suggesting thousands could be dead. Automatic assessments from the US Geological Survey (USGS) said the shallow 7.7-magnitude quake northwest of the central Myanmar city of Sagaing triggered a red alert for shaking-related fatalities and economic losses. “High casualties and extensive damage are probable and the disaster is likely widespread,” it said, locating the epicentre near the central Myanmar city of Mandalay, home to more than a million people. Myanmar’s ruling junta said on Saturday morning that the number killed had