In 1978, Harvey Milk, gay activist and San Francisco city supervisor, was shot to death along with mayor George Moscone by fellow supervisor Dan White. Thirty years later, Gus van Sant’s much-anticipated Milk told the story of the late politician, considered by many to be the modern gay movement’s first martyr. The movie garnered widespread critical acclaim, with Sean Penn winning his second Oscar for playing the role of Milk.
But fewer people are familiar with accomplished documentary maker Rob Epstein’s 1984 film The Times of Harvey Milk, an Oscar-winning documentary that served as the blueprint for Van Sant’s feature.
The two-week long mini retrospective on Epstein currently showing at SPOT — Taipei Film House presents four award-winning documentary works by the American director, an artist known for raising mainstream awareness about gay-related issues through his polished, non-fictional films.
Epstein takes the audience on a journey through Milk’s life, a chronicle suffused with poignant emotion. A project that began before Milk was murdered, The Times of Harvey Milk, composed of exclusive documentary and archival footage, combines original interviews with news reports to create a gripping work that extends its gaze far beyond the specifics of Milk’s life. Set in the volatile political and social climate of 1970s San Francisco, the film depicts Milk as an everyday man who chose to speak out on behalf of both his own community and other minorities. Epstein juxtaposes Milk’s rise and demise with the career of White, a man supposedly representative of the “old-fashioned values that built this country.”
Much of the film’s emotional urgency stems from the testimonies of Milk’s friends and associates. Particularly resonant interviews center on the exaltation Milk and his allies experienced after their successful campaign to bar Proposition 6, the proposed California ordinance prohibiting homosexuals from teaching in public schools. The immense impact that Milk’s subsequent death had on the gay community is reflected in both images of the candlelight procession on the night of the murders and the severity of the riots that followed White’s lenient sentence (White was paroled after serving less than six years for his conviction of voluntary manslaughter).
Recounted with equally strong emotion and blessed with similarly distinctive characters, the Oscar-winning Common Threads: Stories from the Quilt (1989) documents the first decade of the American HIV epidemic through the eyes of five individuals featured on the AIDS Memorial Quilt. Narrated by Dustin Hoffmann, the film appeals to more mainstream audiences, bolstered by its high production value and smooth narrative flow.
The stories that the film follows are immensely compelling. As the five interviewees speak of their experiences watching their loved ones die of AIDS, these oral histories are punctuated by news reports criticizing governmental inertia, as well as accounts of the public fear and hysteria that surrounded the disease. The footage is well edited and progresses towards a tear-inducing climax. In addition to its sentimental impact, the film holds historical value, as first-person witness accounts provide future generations with vital lessons from the not-so-distant past.
Epstein and filmmaker Jeffrey Friedman shift their focus to a lesser-known atrocity in the movie Paragraph 175 (2000), the title of which refers to a statute that once prohibited homosexuality in Third Reich Germany. Narrated by actor Rupert Everett, the film draws upon the testimonies of six survivors of the Nazi persecution of homosexuals, a purge that resulted in both the condemnation of approximately 10,000 to 15,000 to concentration camps and the arrest of 100,000.
The reluctance of the elderly interviewees to speak is as telling as their words. In an emotional outburst, one survivor recounts a Nazi experiment so horrific that it still makes him bleed every day. Another recalls “the singing forest,” a name that alludes to the locale where gay men subjected to torture wailed and screamed. No less disturbing is German historian Klaus Muller’s comment that, despite growing up in Germany, he never heard about the mass persecution of gays.
The most entertaining and enjoyable of the four films, The Celluloid Closet (1995) delivers a comprehensive review of the ways in which gays and lesbians have been represented in Hollywood cinema. The work ingeniously juxtaposes clips from various movies to construct a persuasive argument about the evolution of homosexual imagery through the cinematic medium, as films ranging from 1912’s Algie, the Miner to 1993’s Philadelphia are re-examined. In elegantly tracing the progression of the homosexual onscreen image, The Celluloid Closet follows the development of the gay archetype from the effeminate laughable sissy to the evil villain or vamp to the pitiful wretch to, finally, real-life characters.
The well-executed film is fun to watch, adorned with witty opinions from gay and straight celebrities alike, including Tom Hanks, Whoopi Goldberg, Susan Sarandon, Tony Curtis and Harvey Fierstein. One highlight is writer Gore Vidal’s hilarious account of his introduction of the gay character Masala in the 1959 epic movie Ben Hur.
Last month historian Stephen Wertheim of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace published an opinion piece in the New York Times with suggestions for an “America First” foreign policy for Democratic presidential candidate Kamala Harris. Of course China and Taiwan received a mention. “Under presidents Trump and Biden,” Wertheim contends, “the world’s top two powers have descended into open rivalry, with tensions over Taiwan coming to the fore.” After complaining that Washington is militarizing the Taiwan issue, he argues that “In truth, Beijing has long proved willing to tolerate the island’s self-rule so long as Taiwan does not declare independence
Big changes are afoot in global politics, which that are having a big impact on the global order, look set to continue and have the potential to completely reshape it. In my previous column we examined the three macro megatrends impacting the entire planet: Technology, demographics and climate. Below are international trends that are social, political, geopolitical and economic. While there will be some impact on Taiwan from all four, it is likely the first two will be minor, but the second two will likely change the course of Taiwan’s history. The re-election of Donald Trump as president of the US
The Mountains to Sea National Greenway (山海圳國家綠道) draws its name from the idea that each hiker starting at the summit of Jade Mountain (玉山) and following the trail to the coast is like a single raindrop. Together, many raindrops form life and prosperity-bringing waterways. Replicating a raindrop’s journey holds poetic beauty, but all hikers know that climbing is infinitely more appealing, and so this installment picks up where the last one left off — heading inland and uphill along the 49.8-kilometer Canal Trail (大圳之路) — second of the Greenway’s four sections. A detailed map of the trail can be found
“Bro, I can’t wait for my first dead body,” wrote an 11-year-old boy on Instagram in Sweden, where gangs recruit children too young to be prosecuted as contract killers on chat apps. “Stay motivated, it’ll come,” answered his 19-year-old contact. He went on to offer the child 150,000 kronor (US$13,680) to carry out a murder, as well as clothes and transport to the scene of the crime, according to a police investigation of the exchange last year in the western province of Varmland. In this case, four men aged 18 to 20 are accused of recruiting four minors aged 11 to 17
RSS