So what do you do if you are the newly elected president of a small, relatively impoverished country whose greatest claim to fame, besides arguably the finest beaches in the world, is the fact that it is slowly sinking into the sea? You lose no time reminding the world of that fact, obviously. And to underline the urgency of the problem, you reveal the startling news that you are seriously thinking about moving the whole nation somewhere else.
That at least is what Mohamed Nasheed, the first democratically elected president of the Maldives, did this week. He aims to start setting aside a chunk of his country’s sizeable tourist revenue to set up a land-purchase fund. “We can do nothing to stop climate change on our own, so we have to buy land elsewhere. It’s an insurance policy for the worst-possible outcome,” he said on the eve of his inauguration. “We do not want to leave the Maldives, but we also do not want to be climate refugees living in tents for decades.”
It is an intriguing, if deeply depressing idea: the first nation on earth to be forced to abandon its homeland because of the impact of global warming and steadily rising sea levels. Nasheed is basically talking about relocating the Maldives’ 300,000-strong population to nearby India, or Sri Lanka or, possibly, Australia. But even if you accept the necessity of such a grim scenario, is it actually feasible? Could an entire people simply move to a new country, set up home there and pick up their lives again as if nothing bar the unfortunate disappearance of their old base had actually happened?
The current consensus seems to be that it is not. “It would be very difficult for a state, as such, to move,” says Graham Price, head of the Asia program at the Royal Institute of International Affairs. “There can be ad-hoc migration, of course, even of quite large numbers. But there are big jurisdictional issues here, issues of sovereignty. That said, it is a real problem, and one we’re going to have to get used to. Nasheed is saying to the rest of the world, we really have to think about this. We want to stay together, we don’t want to lose our culture, and this isn’t our fault.”
No one doubts the Maldives’ crisis is real. Made up of nearly 1,200 islands and atolls — 200 of them inhabited — in the Indian Ocean, it holds the record for the country with the lowest high point on earth: nowhere on the Maldives does the natural ground level exceed 2.3m. Most of its landmass, which totals roughly one-fifth of Greater London, is a great deal lower than that, averaging around 1.5m.
So, climate change will affect the Maldives more than most places. Sea levels in the area have risen by about 20cm in the past century, and the UN estimates that they will rise a further 58cm by 2100. The country and its capital, Male, were inundated by unusually high tides in 1987 that caused millions of US dollars worth of damage. The Asian tsunami of Dec. 26, 2004 was even more devastating. The wave that struck the Maldives was barely 1m high, but it killed 82 people, displaced 12,000 more and inflicted US$375 million of damage (including US$100 million to the exclusive beachside resorts).
Tourists may be vital to the Maldives’ economy, but they are all but ignorant of its problems. The country is known as one of the world’s most upmarket destinations, its luxurious beachside bungalows proving particularly popular with honeymooning couples. Nearly 90 otherwise uninhabited islands have been turned into resorts that pull in more than 600,000 mostly European visitors each year. But while the average visitor apparently spends around US$300 a day, they will rarely come into contact with local Maldivians, transported to their atoll by speedboat or small plane, and never stepping off it except for the odd day cruise.
This industry, though, accounts directly for maybe one-third of the Maldives’ GDP and at least 60 percent of its foreign exchange. Import duties and tourism-related taxes generate more than 90 percent of the government’s income; there is precious little other economic activity on the islands except for fishing. Few of those visitors are going to want to keep on coming once their accommodation risks slipping, at any moment, beneath the waves.
The Maldives has been working for some time on one possible solution: constructing a new island, Hulu Male, or New Male, to which it hopes to be able to transfer the populations of some of its lowest-lying atolls and, eventually, the capital, currently one of the most densely populated towns in the world. “They’ve been dredging the waters around the existing island to raise it to above the 2.1m-mark,” says Saleemul Huq, head of the climate-change group at the International Institute for Environment and Development. Some of the smallest inhabited atolls, Huq says, “are thinking in terms of relocation,” but only, at this stage, within the archipelago.
Longer term, though, “if the measures we are taking to counter global warming do not prove sufficient, then it may well be that people will have to be moved further afield.” Such eventualities are being discussed already, Huq says, with the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change providing an initial forum to talk through the “adaptation” of the most vulnerable countries. The island of Tuvalu, for example, is in talks with Australia about much the same kind of idea.
“But it’s plain,” Huq adds, “that the relocation of entire populations is a source of major potential conflict.” The Maldivian president mentioned India, Sri Lanka or Australia as possible hosts for his island people. In the case of the first two, at least, cultural differences for Maldivians would be minimal (many islanders already work there, and wealthy Maldivians have been buying themselves homes in Sri Lanka for years). Amid India’s 1.13 billion people, 300,000 Maldivians would not be a lot. But quite apart from the human cost of uprooting them, the international legal system is simply not up to the job.
“There isn’t really a big plot of land in either country which you could say is available,” says Price. “There’s a possible parallel with the case of the Bhutanese refugees in Nepal — the US has volunteered to take 60,000 of them. But that is a group of people, not a nation. And it’s hard to see what the Maldivians would do wherever they were to go: all they have is tourism and fishing. If they have money, I suppose somewhere in Africa might volunteer — maybe a place like Zanzibar could work? But the real problems would be constitutional: a state cannot play host to another state. In the case of Sri Lanka at least, the whole cause of its civil war is precisely this kind of federal issue.”
Some experts see further legal problems down the line. The Inventory of Conflict and Environment, based at American University in Washington, foresees potential for conflict within and beyond the Maldives increasing as sea levels around the country rise. “It is possible that the Maldives would seek to be compensated by polluting countries for the loss of their islands,” it suggests in an advisory paper.
“However, it is unclear whether the Maldives would seek new sovereign territory elsewhere. Additionally, it is unclear whether the Maldives would seek that territory in neighboring countries or elsewhere, such as in countries that contributed to the climate change in the first place like the US or China. Will a country that is threatened or destroyed by global warming demand compensation for its loss? Would the Maldives try to claim Washington, DC — which is roughly the same size as the Maldives’ territory — as compensation for the US’ role in contributing to global warming?”
On a hillside overlooking Taichung are the remains of a village that never was. Half-formed houses abandoned by investors are slowly succumbing to the elements. Empty, save for the occasional explorer. Taiwan is full of these places. Factories, malls, hospitals, amusement parks, breweries, housing — all facing an unplanned but inevitable obsolescence. Urbex, short for urban exploration, is the practice of exploring and often photographing abandoned and derelict buildings. Many urban explorers choose not to disclose the locations of the sites, as a way of preserving the structures and preventing vandalism or looting. For artist and professor at NTNU and Taipei
March 10 to March 16 Although it failed to become popular, March of the Black Cats (烏貓進行曲) was the first Taiwanese record to have “pop song” printed on the label. Released in March 1929 under Eagle Records, a subsidiary of the Japanese-owned Columbia Records, the Hoklo (commonly known as Taiwanese) lyrics followed the traditional seven characters per verse of Taiwanese opera, but the instrumentation was Western, performed by Eagle’s in-house orchestra. The singer was entertainer Chiu-chan (秋蟾). In fact, a cover of a Xiamen folk song by Chiu-chan released around the same time, Plum Widow Missing Her Husband (雪梅思君), enjoyed more
Last week Elbridge Colby, US President Donald Trump’s nominee for under secretary of defense for policy, a key advisory position, said in his Senate confirmation hearing that Taiwan defense spending should be 10 percent of GDP “at least something in that ballpark, really focused on their defense.” He added: “So we need to properly incentivize them.” Much commentary focused on the 10 percent figure, and rightly so. Colby is not wrong in one respect — Taiwan does need to spend more. But the steady escalation in the proportion of GDP from 3 percent to 5 percent to 10 percent that advocates
From insomniacs to party-goers, doting couples, tired paramedics and Johannesburg’s golden youth, The Pantry, a petrol station doubling as a gourmet deli, has become unmissable on the nightlife scene of South Africa’s biggest city. Open 24 hours a day, the establishment which opened three years ago is a haven for revelers looking for a midnight snack to sober up after the bars and nightclubs close at 2am or 5am. “Believe me, we see it all here,” sighs a cashier. Before the curtains open on Johannesburg’s infamous party scene, the evening gets off to a gentle start. On a Friday at around 6pm,
RSS