When curators at the Ho Chuang-shih Calligraphy Society (
The traditionalists claim works that contain unrecognizable characters should not be classified as calligraphy. Such works should instead be described as abstract or calligraphy-influenced art. The modernists on the other hand argue that the rules the traditionalists abide by are outdated and should be reformulated in order to make calligraphy relevant to today's society.
PHOTO COURTESY OF HO CHUANG-SHIH CALLIGRAPHY SOCIETY
Some of those responsible for challenging traditional calligraphic norms are members of Taiwan's only avant-garde calligraphy group, the Mochao or Ink Tide Society (
PHOTO COURTESY OF HSU YUNG-CHIN
The Ink Tide Society conveyed its message by incorporating calligraphy into installation art, turning characters upside down and inside out or writing in a variety of colors. The group's work was often so radical and contrary to calligraphic norms that many galleries remained apprehensive of exhibiting their works until the early 1990s.
"Many called it a betrayal of tradition. The traditionalists and critics who were brought up to believe that calligraphy can only be presented in one particular pattern were outraged," says Yang Tse-yun (
PHOTO COURTESY OF HSU YUNG-CHIN
"Of course, they had to be careful what they said, as the people they were criticizing to weren't unqualified. All the members [of the Ink Tide Society] were teaching art and traditional calligraphy full-time and were well known in the calligraphy community," Yang said, pointing out that the group was simply creating works that "were beyond the imagination of those calligraphers who persisted in following tradition."
Experimentation within the art of calligraphy is by no means new. During the 1940s, Japanese calligrapher Ueda Kuwabapo (
The acceptance of non-traditional calligraphy has taken longer in Taiwan. Works by contemporary calligraphers are closely scrutinized by conservatives, who want to ensure that calligraphy does not veer away from tradition.
Even before the current exhibition in Taipei opened, traditionalists and modernists had exchanged heated words. A work entitled Wei An Fu (
"The traditionalists called it a painting. They said the three characters `wei' (
"The excuse they gave as to why I had to re-do the work was rubbish. The rules as to what is and what isn't calligraphy are not written in stone; they are written by the traditionalists who are set in their ways and will never change. We are trying to bring calligraphy into the present day ... [We want to] make it accessible to the younger generations of people who haven't been taught about calligraphy, but who should still be able to enjoy it."
Making calligraphy more accessible to younger generations is also important to traditionalists. This is one point -- probably the only point -- on which the two camps agree, although they are poles apart on how this should be achieved.
"It was a nude. He tried to use the characters to create a nude and call it calligraphy," states Fu Shen (
"It wasn't calligraphy; it was an abstract painting. We've said that for a work to be called calligraphy it must contain readable characters and be two-dimensional. These rules are very clear, and Hsu broke them knowingly. I mean, when you're asked to play basketball you don't kick the ball. So why did he paint a picture?"
Hsu is adamant, however, that the work was never a painting. The fault, according to Hsu, lies with those who can't see the whole picture, rather than with him or his work.
"It boils down to the fact that after 25 years our group and the work we do has been noticed, and people are taking an interest. Which is more than can be said of traditional calligraphy. Okay, it is still very popular, but it has stagnated. It isn't going anywhere. It isn't changing with the times," said Hsu. "I created the Wei An Fu piece to be topical and up to date. What happens? A group of traditionalists who have no idea what contemporary calligraphy is come along and criticize it. They don't understand what we are trying to do with calligraphy. We've never criticized the art of calligraphy; we've simply been developing the content and the way it is presented."
All the same, Hsu resubmitted the work in a form that was acceptable to the exhibition's selection panel.
While remaining staunchly critical of contemporary calligraphy, Fu Shen believes that there is scope for development for the ancient art that does not transgress the basic rules of traditional calligraphy.
"There's nothing wrong with going beyond tradition. But you have to follow the rules. There's certainly nothing wrong with abstract works. Art is art after all. But such art is not [necessarily] calligraphy," explains Fu.
In 1999, Fu created his own contemporary piece. Titled The Speck of Dust (
"I chose to use characters from a poem written by Tao Yuan-ming (陶淵明). The characters are based on styles employed during the Chin Dynasty (晉, 365-420AD), but by presenting them as boldly as I have, the work looks very contemporary," states Fu. "It proves that calligraphers can still look to tradition for ideas and inspiration and still create a calligraphic work that is both recognizable and strikingly different."
Another avenue being explored by contemporary calligraphers is the incorporation of social or political criticism into their works. Two recent pieces by Ink Tide-member Lien Te-sen (
But according to Fu, while these works do take calligraphy to extremes, neither of them breaks any of the calligraphic rules adhered to by the traditionalists. The mediums might not be traditional -- Fo was created using plaster molded into the form of rose petals and Two Nations Two Systems with plastic topped pins -- but the characters are recognizable and the works both follow lines of traditional presentation.
Of course, not all works created from mediums other than ink can be called calligraphy. Hsu will be the first to admit that it will be some time before the traditionalists will allow that a piece he created in 1994 using a long piece of red cotton spread across a field constitutes calligraphy.
While the traditionalists and modernists will, no doubt, continue to disagree on calligraphic matters, the future of calligraphy looks set to be both colorful and distinctive as both sides push the ancient art to its limits and beyond.
Art Notes:
What: 25th anniversary exhibition of the Ink Tide Society (
Where: Ho Chuang-shih Calligraphy Society (
When: Until June 24
Taiwan doesn’t have a lot of railways, but its network has plenty of history. The government-owned entity that last year became the Taiwan Railway Corp (TRC) has been operating trains since 1891. During the 1895-1945 period of Japanese rule, the colonial government made huge investments in rail infrastructure. The northern port city of Keelung was connected to Kaohsiung in the south. New lines appeared in Pingtung, Yilan and the Hualien-Taitung region. Railway enthusiasts exploring Taiwan will find plenty to amuse themselves. Taipei will soon gain its second rail-themed museum. Elsewhere there’s a number of endearing branch lines and rolling-stock collections, some
Could Taiwan’s democracy be at risk? There is a lot of apocalyptic commentary right now suggesting that this is the case, but it is always a conspiracy by the other guys — our side is firmly on the side of protecting democracy and always has been, unlike them! The situation is nowhere near that bleak — yet. The concern is that the power struggle between the opposition Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and their now effectively pan-blue allies the Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) and the ruling Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) intensifies to the point where democratic functions start to break down. Both
The Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT), and the country’s other political groups dare not offend religious groups, says Chen Lih-ming (陳立民), founder of the Taiwan Anti-Religion Alliance (台灣反宗教者聯盟). “It’s the same in other democracies, of course, but because political struggles in Taiwan are extraordinarily fierce, you’ll see candidates visiting several temples each day ahead of elections. That adds impetus to religion here,” says the retired college lecturer. In Japan’s most recent election, the Liberal Democratic Party lost many votes because of its ties to the Unification Church (“the Moonies”). Chen contrasts the progress made by anti-religion movements in
This was not supposed to be an election year. The local media is billing it as the “2025 great recall era” (2025大罷免時代) or the “2025 great recall wave” (2025大罷免潮), with many now just shortening it to “great recall.” As of this writing the number of campaigns that have submitted the requisite one percent of eligible voters signatures in legislative districts is 51 — 35 targeting Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) caucus lawmakers and 16 targeting Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) lawmakers. The pan-green side has more as they started earlier. Many recall campaigns are billing themselves as “Winter Bluebirds” after the “Bluebird Action”
RSS