From building the world’s biggest dam to engineering blue skies for the Olympics, China’s leaders have earned a reputation for achieving improbable goals.
So when the Chinese government declared last April that it wanted to make Shanghai an international financial center by 2020, the news sent a ripple of anxiety through Hong Kong.
The authorities were anointing Shanghai as the country’s financial center and Hong Kong, the financial metropolis on China’s southern coast, seemed sure to lose out.
T.C. Chan (陳子政), a well-known Hong Kong banker, captured the mood.
“Will Hong Kong become a Boston?” he asked.
“If you can be a New York, you don’t want to be Boston or Chicago,” he added, referring to two cities that have long lived in the shadow of the US’ main financial and cultural center.
Shanghai is indeed working hard to transform itself into the region’s New York. New skyscrapers continue to rise, including the 101-story Shanghai World Finance Center, meant to be the Asian headquarters for international banks. The city is expanding its subway system in preparation for the 2010 World Expo.
And financial reforms are on the table again.
“A number of long-anticipated capital markets initiatives that were put on the backburner in late 2007 are now returning to the forefront,” said Jing Ulrich (李晶), chairman of China equities and commodities for JPMorgan.
Those include index-tracking exchange-traded funds, a program to allow foreign companies to list on local exchanges and long-awaited financial and commodity futures.
But the outcome of the Shanghai-Hong Kong rivalry is not clear. In many respects, Hong Kong has an edge. While Shanghai’s market capitalization is larger, the Hong Kong Exchange (HKEx) boasts more listed companies: 1,297 compared with 869 in Shanghai. Hong Kong has also emerged as the world’s most popular venue for initial public offerings this year.
Hong Kong, a city where US$300,000 Ferraris were common even at the peak of the crisis, enjoys certain first-mover advantages. It has accumulated not just an enviable collection of regional headquarters for major banks — the likes of Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan and Morgan Stanley — but also a supporting ecosystem of accountants, lawyers and consultants.
And for all its determination, Shanghai faces high hurdles. First, China’s strict capital controls, though gradually loosening, make the city less attractive to global investors.
Similarly, although the pace of financial reform is set to quicken, it has proven unpredictable. Three years ago, the city prepared to launch a new financial derivatives exchange, only to shelve the plans because of regulators’ worries — the fully staffed exchange has yet to trade a single product.
Finally, foreign bankers are not keen to move there — yet. One reason: Hong Kong’s personal income tax is a flat 15 percent, but in Shanghai the limit is 45 percent. A new tax incentive for bankers will cut the top rate to 25 percent, still higher than in Hong Kong.
“It’s not enough,” said Poling Cheung (張寶玲), China head of business development for KCS, a consultancy spin-off of KPMG.
“Usually at a foreign bank, only eight or nine staffers like CEO or CFO level can be considered by the government as senior executives for the tax rebate benefits so far,” Cheung said.
But many bankers agree that sooner or later Shanghai will become a global financial center. A recent Reuters poll of analysts found that most believe the yuan will be mostly convertible by 2020. And if China’s economic growth continues to outpace other major economies the pull for banks will be irresistible.
“Even before the [yuan] becomes fully convertible, Shanghai may still become a major financial hub simply by virtue of the scale of financial services required to serve the growth of Chinese enterprises and capital markets,” Ulrich said.
In one sign of the shifting currents, Credit Suisse’s Hong Kong office party has a new theme this year, according to bankers: “Shanghai Dreams.”
What will happen to Hong Kong? One scenario is a prosperous coexistence.
“This is an issue of the pie getting bigger rather than a zero-sum game,” said Ronald Arculli, the 70-year-old chairman of the HKEx, saying that Hong Kong’s advantages will help it grab a large piece of mainland-related fund flows.
“Today you have a market that is restricted in mainland China. But when everything is open it is just like us competing with New York and London over the past 10 years,” he said.
Arculli did not rule out a future tie-up between HKEx and either the Shanghai or Shenzhen exchanges, however.
A second scenario is that Shanghai will become a big, mostly domestic market, leaving Hong Kong as the preferred route to overseas capital.
Tjun Tang (鄧俊豪), a partner with Boston Consulting Group, said that in the medium-term Shanghai could be handling China’s yuan trade and investment flows while Hong Kong would focus on regional markets.
“The parallel is London and Frankfurt,” he said. “When the euro zone came in, people said that financial markets would decamp from London to Frankfurt. Well, that didn’t happen. But Frankfurt did rise and filled another important role in the market.”
Arthur Kroeber, managing director at Beijing-based research firm Dragonomics, said that in any case Beijing appeared more interested in bolstering domestic capital markets than in competing internationally.
“This has nothing to do with creating an international financial center,” Kroeber said, referring to the 2020 target. “This gives Shanghai a license to be aggressive in building a domestics capital markets infrastructure.”
There is, of course, another possibility: second-tier status for Hong Kong.
“If our markets are liberalized, it will be easy for Shanghai to surpass other markets,” said a senior Shanghai Stock Exchange official who wasn’t authorized to speak with the media. “We can be bigger than Hong Kong. Even bigger than New York.”
War, possibly global, will define the coming decade — so it is crucial that Taiwanese decide now what their freedom and their lives are worth — perhaps starting with a defense budget of 5 percent of Gross Domestic Product (GDP). The force that threatens Taiwan, the Communist Party of China (CCP) and its People’s Liberation Army (PLA), asserts that a free, or even worse, an “independent” Taiwan is the greatest threat to the CCP’s dictatorship. Accordingly, they are prepared to kill Taiwanese by the millions, which also will initiate their longer war against democracies. Should it succeed, Chinese sources are all but openly
Vincent Gao (高志凱), vice president of the Center for China and Globalization and former interpreter for Deng Xiaoping (鄧小平) recently gave an interview with al-Jazeera’s Mehdi Hasan in which Gao appeared overwhelmed on multiple occasions. When asked about sensitive topics such as Taiwan and Xinjiang, Gao attempted to adhere to the official position of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), but quickly succumbed to Hasan’s precise and consistent questioning, which exposed the flaws in the CCP’s positions. His views on unification with Taiwan were also widely criticized. Throughout the interview, Gao reiterated the importance of “one China.” He said it is “not
Amid China’s escalating military harassment of Taiwan, a teaser released on July 23 of the new TV series Zero Day (零日攻擊), a local production portraying a Chinese attack on Taiwan, attracted more than 1 million views in a week, sparking an emotional response and discussions across the nation. Partly funded by the government and scheduled to air next year, ‘Zero Day’ depicts a Chinese warplane disappearing in the Taiwan Strait and China using the search as an excuse to mount a naval blockade of Taiwan and launch an invasion. The 17-minute trailer shows clips how Beijing could increase its choke hold
Oil, copper, soybeans and a handful of others monopolized the attention — but of all commodities, the humble lump of iron ore benefited the most from the Chinese economic boom of the past 25 years. It was an astonishing bonanza: From the late 1990s to earlier this year, iron ore prices jumped nearly 10-fold, more than any other major commodity; traded volume tripled; Australian commodity tycoons become billionaires; mining companies turned, even briefly, into Wall Street darlings; and mighty legal battles broke for control of the last untapped mineral deposits. Now, it is over: The greatest commodity boom thus far of the