Many aspects of the government’s handling of the Formosa Chieftain 2 sports fishing boat incident are praiseworthy, but now that the vessel has been impounded by Japanese authorities, other aspects require careful thought before action is taken.
In terms of maritime law, most worrying is the likelihood that the boat and crew were taken by the Japanese west of the temporary enforcement line between Japan and Taiwan — that is, in Taiwanese waters. It’s akin to a Taiwanese accused of a crime overseas returning home, only to be detained by foreign authorities and taken out of the country without the knowledge of the Taiwanese government.
In 1961, when the British trawler Red Crusader was fishing illegally near the Faroe Islands, the crew of the Danish frigate Niels Ebbessen boarded the trawler to guide it to port, but the Red Crusader continued toward Aberdeen, hurriedly leaving Danish waters with the Niels Ebbessen in pursuit.
The British warship Troubridge came to the trawler’s assistance and placed itself between the two boats, blocking the Danish ship on the high seas while the trawler made its way to Aberdeen.
Denmark said the British warship offered illegal protection, but after the two parties submitted the issue to a neutral commission, no fault was found with the British.
A similar incident involving Japan and South Korea in 2005 highlighted the importance of returning boats and crew to their home country in dealing with maritime disputes.
A South Korean fishing boat was fishing illegally inside Japan’s exclusive economic zone when two Japanese law enforcement officials boarded the boat to investigate. The boat’s captain detained the officials and sailed toward South Korean waters.
After the boat entered the South Korean exclusive economic zone, a stand-off developed between six Japanese and five South Korean vessels, with Japan insisting that the South Korean captain and the boat be returned to its custody.
An agreement was eventually reached, with the South Korean side agreeing to pay a bond and guaranteeing that the incident would be properly investigated in accordance with maritime law.
The Japanese vessels then left and the South Korean fishing boat and crew returned to port for investigation and punishment.
By maritime convention, crews and boats are not extradited, but in the case of the Formosa Chieftain 2, the vessel and crew remain stuck in Japan — a worrying set of circumstances. Worse still, the incident occurred in contested waters and this could have an impact on maritime talks.
Taiwan announced the location of the temporary enforcement line in 2003, but this is the first time that Japan has encroached west of the line to detain Taiwanese fishermen, and even after engaging Taiwan’s coast guard.
President Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) has a deep understanding of international law. Top officials must make clear to the foreign ministry and its agencies that they must protest against Japan’s arrest of Taiwanese crew and its confiscation of a Taiwanese boat in waters west of the enforcement line in order to ensure that this incident does not set a precedent.
Punishment must also be meted out to the crew by a Taiwanese court if the law has been broken.
Illegal conduct on the part of Taiwanese boats must not be indulged, otherwise the ability of ordinary fishermen to do their job could be compromised by cross-border tensions.
Irresponsible behavior encourages fishermen to act as they wish.
If they end up thinking that they have the government’s support in breaking the law, then Taiwan’s relations with Japan could deteriorate
Finally, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Coast Guard Administration should be informed that it is unacceptable for Japan to seize vessels and crew and that this conduct challenges Taiwan’s territorial claims.
Allowing Japan to have a free hand would make an already difficult situation even more difficult.
Chiang Huang-chih is an associate professor at National Taiwan University’s College of Law.
TRANSLATED BY PERRY SVENSSON
US political scientist Francis Fukuyama, during an interview with the UK’s Times Radio, reacted to US President Donald Trump’s overturning of decades of US foreign policy by saying that “the chance for serious instability is very great.” That is something of an understatement. Fukuyama said that Trump’s apparent moves to expand US territory and that he “seems to be actively siding with” authoritarian states is concerning, not just for Europe, but also for Taiwan. He said that “if I were China I would see this as a golden opportunity” to annex Taiwan, and that every European country needs to think
For years, the use of insecure smart home appliances and other Internet-connected devices has resulted in personal data leaks. Many smart devices require users’ location, contact details or access to cameras and microphones to set up, which expose people’s personal information, but are unnecessary to use the product. As a result, data breaches and security incidents continue to emerge worldwide through smartphone apps, smart speakers, TVs, air fryers and robot vacuums. Last week, another major data breach was added to the list: Mars Hydro, a Chinese company that makes Internet of Things (IoT) devices such as LED grow lights and the
Today is Feb. 28, a day that Taiwan associates with two tragic historical memories. The 228 Incident, which started on Feb. 28, 1947, began from protests sparked by a cigarette seizure that took place the day before in front of the Tianma Tea House in Taipei’s Datong District (大同). It turned into a mass movement that spread across Taiwan. Local gentry asked then-governor general Chen Yi (陳儀) to intervene, but he received contradictory orders. In early March, after Chiang Kai-shek (蔣介石) dispatched troops to Keelung, a nationwide massacre took place and lasted until May 16, during which many important intellectuals
US President Donald Trump is an extremely stable genius. Within his first month of presidency, he proposed to annex Canada and take military action to control the Panama Canal, renamed the Gulf of Mexico, called Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy a dictator and blamed him for the Russian invasion. He has managed to offend many leaders on the planet Earth at warp speed. Demanding that Europe step up its own defense, the Trump administration has threatened to pull US troops from the continent. Accusing Taiwan of stealing the US’ semiconductor business, it intends to impose heavy tariffs on integrated circuit chips
RSS