Separated by a road and a viscous finger of black, garbage-choked water, the stilt-house slum of Muara Baru and the BMW car dealership that faces it appear as if from different worlds.
But on Dec. 6, 2025, these two extremes of the Indonesian capital will have something in common as a World Bank study shows that unless action is taken, they and much of the coastal city of 12 million will be submerged by seawater.
Experts have pinpointed that date as the next peak of an 18.6-year astronomical cycle, when sea levels will rise enough to engulf much of Indonesia’s low-lying capital.
Climate change is causing sea levels to rise, but the study’s authors say that the main problem is that Jakarta is sinking under the weight of out-of-control development.
CLIMATE CHANGE?
“The major reason for this is not climate change or whatever, but just the sinking of Jakarta,” said JanJaap Brinkman, an engineer with Dutch consultancy Delft Hydraulics who worked with the World Bank on the study.
“We can exactly predict to what extent the sea will come into Jakarta,” Brinkman said.
By 2025, estimates from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change show that sea levels will have risen by only about 5cm.
But Brinkman says Jakarta, which spans a flat plain between mountains and coast, will be between 40cm and 60cm lower than it is now.
The study shows that without better defenses, in 2025 the sea will reach the presidential palace around 5km inland as well as completely inundating Jakarta’s historic old city to the north.
Dec. 6 will be the highest point of the tidal cycle, but Brinkman warns there are likely to be plenty of floods before then.
Brinkman blames the swelling city’s over-development, which is compressing the land it is built on.
LITTLE PROGRESS
The problem has been exacerbated by factories, hotels and wealthy residents drilling deep water bores to bypass the city’s shambolic water grid, sucking out the groundwater and causing further subsidence.
The World Bank has called for a halt to deep groundwater extraction, and the city administration has raised the price of groundwater but so far there has been little progress.
“If you do nothing about the groundwater problem, parts of Jakarta will sink 5m [by 2025],” Brinkman said.
A glimpse of the future can be seen in the shacks of Muara Baru, where the city’s north meets the sea, and where flood levels late last year reached up to 2m.
The few trees that shaded this fishing slum were underwater for so long they are now dead and bare.
Muara Baru is bordered by just the kind of high-rise towers, luxury homes and megamalls that are pushing the area into the sea.
There is little water to drink in the slum itself — around 40 percent of Jakarta’s population is not connected to the water grid, said Achmad Lanti, the city’s water regulator.
PRIVATIZATION
Jakarta’s water was privatized in 1997 in the hope of improving services. But Lanti said the two foreign operators brought in to run it had failed to live up to pledges to bring water to 75 percent of the population by last year.
The shortage leaves many Jakartans with limited options: Buy the water at a marked-up price, dig for it, or steal it.
Around half of the water from Jakarta’s pipes disappears through a combination of leaks and theft, Lanti said.
“Sometimes [those who steal] are only individuals, sometimes they form a kind of organized crime, what I call a water mafia,” he said.
In Muara Baru, Sayong, a 65-year-old grandmother, and Aris, who says he is in his 70s, skid down hill holding a pushcart filled with jugs of fresh water.
Each day Sayong fills three carts full of water from a pump and sells it on to other residents. After using the water she needs and selling the rest, Sayong, who lives with two adult children and two grandchildren, said she earns a maximum of 20,000 rupiah (US$2.20) a day.
THREAT
Her tiny income means she has no option but to stay in Muara Baru, where the floods are a constant threat.
“It’s serious, I can’t sleep because I’m always afraid that there will be flooding from the sea,” she said..
The waste-filled canal that runs up to the slum’s edge shows the effect of the city’s chaotic development.
Massive buildings have taken over natural drainage sites, while human waste and rubbish clog waterways, causing freshwater floods that surge up from the ground during the rainy season.
The drainage system built by the Dutch who once ruled Jakarta is unable to cope with the city’s rapid growth, said Hongjoo Hahm, the top infrastructure specialist at the World Bank in Indonesia.
“Every year we get floods,” he said. “The scale of the floods [the Dutch] were talking about every 25 years are happening every year.”
Former US president Jimmy Carter’s legacy regarding Taiwan is a complex tapestry woven with decisions that, while controversial, were instrumental in shaping the nation’s path and its enduring relationship with the US. As the world reflects on Carter’s life and his recent passing at the age of 100, his presidency marked a transformative era in Taiwan-US-China relations, particularly through the landmark decision in 1978 to formally recognize the People’s Republic of China (PRC) as the sole legal government of China, effectively derecognizing the Republic of China (ROC) based in Taiwan. That decision continues to influence geopolitical dynamics and Taiwan’s unique
Having enjoyed contributing regular essays to the Liberty Times and Taipei Times now for several years, I feel it is time to pull back. As some of my readers know, I have enjoyed a decades-long relationship with Taiwan. My most recent visit was just a few months ago, when I was invited to deliver a keynote speech at a major conference in Taipei. Unfortunately, my trip intersected with Double Ten celebrations, so I missed the opportunity to call on friends in government, as well as colleagues in the new AIT building, that replaced the old Xin-yi Road complex. I have
On New Year’s Day, it is customary to reflect on what the coming year might bring and how the past has brought about the current juncture. Just as Taiwan is preparing itself for what US president-elect Donald Trump’s second term would mean for its economy, national security and the cross-strait “status quo” this year, the passing of former US president Jimmy Carter on Monday at the age of 100 brought back painful memories of his 1978 decision to stop recognizing the Republic of China as the seat of China in favor of the People’s Republic of China. It is an
After forcing through a slew of controversial amendments, the opposition Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) on Tuesday last week rejected all seven Constiutional Court candidates nominated by President William Lai (賴清德), an event that triggered public concerns that it could lead to an unprecedented constitutional crisis and jeopardize Taiwan’s democracy. The opposition parties on Dec. 20 forced through three controversial amendments to the Public Officials Election and Recall Act (公職人員選舉罷免法), the Act Governing the Allocation of Government Revenues and Expenditures (財政收支劃分法) and the Constitutional Court Procedure Act (憲法訴訟法). The amendment to tighten the recall process has been