Wed, Apr 20, 2005 page8

• Blame where blame's due

  • By Darin ten Bruggencate
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  Having lived in Japan for some time, I feel that I understand how the Japanese government is less than perfect.

  And after taking many history courses at my Japanese university, I have seen first hand how many Japanese feel about the textbook and other problems.

  Which brings me to my point. After the anti-Japan demonstrations -- or riots -- began, I started to think about how many of the Chinese students I have met have very different memories to mine, and I began to wonder if the history taught in China, like that taught anywhere else, was less than complete in a few areas.

  With the recent outbreaks in China against Japan, I started to wonder why the Chinese government and people have hard feelings toward Japan over disputed islands.

  Is it not true that South Korea, North Korea and Taiwan also claim ownership of these islands?

  And why has China not made any complaints until recent years? China, which preaches the status quo on the Taiwan issue, is doing anything but that and trying to drag Japan into a long legal battle over an issue that has been ignored for nearly 50 years.

  I suspect that China's recent interest in the islands was sparked by the discovery of oil. I would like to know why China has not said anything to any other nations about these islands.

  I would also like to say that I agree with Japan on protecting Japanese people and interests in China. It is clearly China's responsibility to defend the Japanese embassy in China, and it seems fairly obvious to me that China is doing nothing to protect it.

  What would China say if Japanese civilians started to attack the Chinese embassy in Tokyo?

  What would China say if Japanese citizens took to the streets in protest every time a Chinese person in Japan committed a crime?

  I'm thinking of events that took place two years ago where two Chinese students studying in Japan murdered their teacher and their teacher's family in an attempt to gain bank-account information, and how not two weeks goes by without something on the news about a Chinese student committing a violent crime either against another student or a Japanese civilian.

  I do, however, agree with Asian nations seeking compensation from the Japanese over the atrocities committed during World War II, and I feel that most Japanese citizens do too.

  However, I disagree with the way China and other nations are going about this.

  The ordinary Japanese public did not commit the crimes, and the Japanese government did not commit the crimes either. The Japanese Empire, no longer in existence, committed those crimes, and neither Japan nor its people should have to pay for them.

  Instead, I feel that these attacks should be aimed at what remains of the empire -- the emperor.

  If groups were to seek compensation from the emperor, I feel that they would receive more support from the world, and from Japanese people themselves.

  Darin ten Bruggencate
  

  Japan
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Taiwan thanks Japan for family registry change

  • 2

    MAC warns of PRC arrests, detentions

  • 3

    Taiwan blacklists two Chinese schools

  • 4

    Inter denied top spot in Serie A by rivals Juve

  • 5

    Actor, 11 others suspected of dodging military service