Sun, May 31, 2009 page12

• Are netbooks losing their shine?

  Netbooks have been the rising stars of the PC market. But with sales slipping, and new rivals appearing, their future is looking less certain.

  • By Jack Schofield / THE GUARDIAN
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  Netbooks have been the PC market’s bright spot for the past nine months, but sales have slipped recently, and they now face an uncertain future. They are losing some of their price advantage over notebooks and soon will be challenged by a new type of ultra-slim notebook PC with a long battery life.

  Netbooks first appeared in 2007 and have been a big success. Sales have far outstripped the predictions of analysts such as Gartner — 14 million units last year, against a forecast of 5.3 milllion — and now make up 20 percent of the portable PC market.

  The Asus marketing specialist John Swatton points to “tech novices” adopting netbooks in the way they have adopted mobile phones and MP3 players, which he says “will drive further growth in the netbook market. We are also seeing more and more users purchasing netbooks as a second, and more portable, device to provide connectivity when away from their primary laptop or PC.”

  

  Teacher Chris Murray, left, helps Trinh Ha, a sixth-grader at the Ann Richards School for Young Women Leaders, as she works with a new Dell netbook during math class on May 19 in Austin, Texas.

  PHOTO: AP

  “The netbook has changed the landscape for good,” says Ian Fogg, an analyst with Forrester. “The netbook category has overturned the idea that users should pay a big price premium for ultraportables.”

  Ultraportable notebook PCs have been available from companies such as IBM and Sony, but they typically cost £1,500 (US$2,425) to £2,500. Today’s netbooks cost around £200 to £300, which makes them affordable enough for everyday commuters. Women like them because they can fit inside a handbag. Kids like them because they can have their own machine, and they may get one from their school — Dell has just launched a rubberized Latitude 2100 in a variety of colors for the education market.

  The netbook has also changed PC retailing, as high-street stores now sell them with USB modems for portable Internet use.

  The Gartner analyst Ranjit Atwal says: “Sales through the telecoms channels have opened up a new target market.”

  The netbook has even changed the competitive landscape for PC manufacturers. The booming netbook market has not been driven by US companies but by three suppliers from Taiwan: Asus, Acer and MicroStar International (MSI).

  On Gartner’s figures for this year’s first quarter, Acer’s sales grew by 26.7 percent in a declining market and it is now shipping roughly as many PCs worldwide as Dell. Because of the success of the Acer Aspire One, the company expects to be the market leader by volume in Europe this year.

  However, the netbook market seems to have slowed. US-based DisplaySearch indicates that while first quarter netbook sales were up by 556 percent compared with the same quarter last year, they were down by 26 percent sequentially, compared with the fourth quarter of last year. Notebook sales declined 24 percent sequentially, so netbooks are no longer growing against the market trend.

  This may be partly to do with the increase in specifications that has pushed up netbook prices. The classic netbook was cheaper than a notebook because it had a 7-inch screen, a small Flash drive, an Intel Atom processor and used Linux instead of Microsoft’s Windows Vista. Today’s netbooks have 10 or 12-inch screens, 160 megabyte hard drives and run Windows XP. It is still cheaper to make a netbook than a notebook, but the gap has narrowed.

  Linux’s failure in the UK market has been striking because the three Taiwanese manufacturers were keen to support it and both Asus and Acer launched their first netbooks with Linux only. But after Microsoft made a cheap version of the supposedly obsolete XP available for ultra-low-cost PCs, Windows took over.

  Acer’s European boss, Massimo D’Angelo, says Linux sales are “very, very minimal” — less than 5 percent — while Asus and MSI have also seen rapid declines.

  MSI’s UK marketing manager, Richard Stewart, says: “We offered Linux for the first six or nine months of the Wind, but, as time went on the gap [to Windows] increased to the point where it wasn’t worthwhile to offer Linux any more. “

  This is not just the failure of Linux, it is the failure of the netbook idea. You were supposed not to need a big hard drive and a powerful processor running Windows because all your applications would be on the Net, and you’d access them via a browser. But it seems most people preferred the system they already knew.

  Atwal says that when consumers buy new phones they are usually prepared to learn a new user interface — “but on a phone, you’re more likely to be viewing rather than creating content. I think that’s the dividing line. When you’re creating content, you’re going to go with Windows.”

  The problem with consuming as against creating, he says, is that “most PC vendors haven’t been able to segment their product lines on that basis, which is why we’re seeing bigger keyboards and screens on netbooks. Then the chance of netbooks taking more of your mainstream market becomes much more apparent.”

  And that could be bad news. Netbooks are cheaper, and have slimmer profit margins, so vendors would rather sell you a notebook. Asus and MSI, of course, had fewer notebook sales to lose.

  Netbooks and notebooks are going to get even closer this year, for two reasons. First, Intel and the PC vendors are launching a new PC platform code-named Montevino Plus, for CULV (Consumer Ultra-Low Voltage) machines. Second, Microsoft is launching Windows 7, which has been optimized so that even the Ultimate version will run pretty well on a netbook.

  Acer looks like being first to market with the new platform in its Timeline series. MSI has also announced its first machine, the X340 X-Slim, which is like a MacBook Air, but lighter and much cheaper. Asus is announcing its new systems at the Computex trade show in Taiwan at the beginning of next month.

  CULV machines will offer a similar sort of battery life to netbooks, perhaps 6-8 hours. They may also weigh about the same — MSI’s X-340 is 1.3kg, in spite of having a 13.4-inch widescreen. But they will have the processing power required for content creation, rather than content consumption.

  Initially, CULV machines will be two or three times the price of netbooks, but PC vendors think they will sell.

  Acer’s UK managing director, Bobby Watkins, says: “Half my demand from the channels [retailers] for the back-to-school period is for Timeline. They believe the pull for it is going to be really, really strong.”

  The result could be that netbooks blend into the bottom part of the notebook market, with screens up to 12 inches in size, rather than being a distinct category. The question is whether consumers will pay for what they appear to want — a light, slim notebook with a decent screen and long battery life — or whether they are buying netbooks mainly on price.

  Microsoft similarly expects the demand for Windows 7 to be strong, and it is encouraging vendors to pre-install the Home Premium version on all the machines aimed at consumers — both netbooks and notebooks. The netbook suppliers want a cheaper version to maintain their price differential. Microsoft has a Starter version that will do the job well on a netbook (where applications are run in the browser) but won’t be much good for notebook use, because it will only run three applications at once.

  The danger is that PC vendors will turn to another free operating system instead: Google’s Android version of Linux, as used in the G1 mobile phone. That could emerge as the big battle over the next year.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Tesla uses Chinese courts to silence critics and make them pay

  • 2

    US removes no independence statement

  • 3

    Taiwan in Time: When the Soviets bombed Taiwan for China

  • 4

    Taiwan thanks Japan for family registry change

  • 5

    MAC warns of PRC arrests, detentions