In 2002, after the dot-com bubble burst, most people were trying hard to forget the preceding years of seemingly irrational entrepreneurial exuberance. But not David Kirsch.
Kirsch, a professor of strategy and entrepreneurship at the University of Maryland, has seen a way to ensure that the next generation of entrepreneurs can avoid the problems of the dot-com bubble, or “at least make new mistakes”: Document what did and didn’t work during the flurry of business activity around the new technology called the Internet.
In June of 2002, he started the Digital Archive of the Birth of the Dot Com Era, usually called the Dot Com Archive (dotcomarchive.org). Shortly thereafter, a partner of a venture capital firm that was closing its doors donated every business plan that the firm had received from 1999 to 2002 — documents covering some 1,100 companies.
PHOTO: NY TIMES NEWS SERVICE
Today, Kirsch says, the archive contains some 6.4 million e-mail messages, memos, slide presentations, photographs, marketing materials and databases representing thousands of companies. These data have begun to reveal interesting insights into the dot-com bubble.
Azi Gera, a doctoral candidate who works with Kirsch, used the archive to reveal the key role that social networks play in venture capital financing. Looking at a data set of 1,018 companies, Gera determined that not a single entrepreneur received venture capital funding by submitting a business plan “over the transom.” By contrast, about 5 percent of entrepreneurs who knew the venture capitalist or gained a personal introduction received funding.
Asked what his finding meant for today’s entrepreneurs, Gera says, “In this economy, the social network will be even more necessary.”
Another striking finding is the high percentage of dot-com businesses that survived the shakeout. Kirsch, along with Brent Goldfarb, a colleague at Maryland, and David Miller of the University of California, San Diego, have found that 48 percent of dot-com companies founded since 1996 were still around in late 2004, more than four years after the NASDAQ’s peak in March 2000.
Kirsch says that most people are stunned by this figure; they tend to guess that about 90 percent of companies failed. He adds that the dot-com survival rate is as good as or better than that for technologies like automobiles, tires and televisions in their formative years.
Many of the companies that survived the dot-com bust did so by ignoring the prevailing “Get Big Fast” business model, Kirsch says. Get Big Fast said that an Internet company should identify a market early and grow as quickly as possible, to shut out all competitors.
Instead, many survivors pursued what Kirsch calls “micro niches”: markets that didn’t offer hundreds of millions in quick profits, but still presented viable Internet-based business opportunities.
WrestlingGear.com, a company that was started in 1998 to sell amateur wrestling equipment to high school students, is a case in point. “It wasn’t rocket science,” says Jeffrey Pape, the company’s founder and president. “One of our focuses when we started was that we had to make money on every transaction. We paid attention to our margins. It was pretty basic.”
He says the company, which is privately held, now has about US$1.4 million in annual sales.
For Marco Rubin, principal of Exoventure Associates, a consulting firm based in Falls Church, Virginia, stories about individual companies are less valuable than the patterns that emerge from the collected data of many businesses. Drawing on data from the archive, conversations with venture capitalists, and a grant from the National Science Foundation, Rubin is building a software tool that he hopes will help early-stage entrepreneurs “avoid known failure patterns.” He is also developing a simulation environment in which entrepreneurs can, as he puts it, “screw up in private” before bringing their ideas to potential investors.
At the archive, Kirsch and Goldfarb have built a database of information on 951 companies that Kirsch says are statistically representative of businesses in the dot-com era; the database does not reveal company or employee names. It includes each company’s location, a brief summary of the proposed business and outcome, and some details about key employees: their ages, educational and work experience, and their personal and professional connections to one another.
Rubin of Exoventure says this information “goes a long way toward taking the voodoo and mysticism out” of the startup process.
For its first five years, the collection of business plans in the Dot Com Archive was easily accessible via the Web, and more than 87,000 people registered to use it. Most of these people were looking for model business plans.
Statistical analysis is undeniably valuable. But a database entry cannot capture the nuances of individual stories that may be instructive for a future entrepreneur. Recognizing this, the Dot Com Archive also collects personal narratives. These may be particularly valuable because they include the experiences of not only successful companies but also of unfunded and failed ones. This offers the opportunity to turn on its head the maxim that “history is written by the winners.”
‘TOO TIRED’: The former mayor’s political party said that he had been questioned for nearly 19 hours, so he declined to be questioned at night, as he felt exhausted Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) Chairman Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) was arrested early yesterday morning after being questioned by prosecutors over his alleged role in a corruption scandal concerning the Core Pacific City redevelopment project during his tenure as Taipei mayor. The arrest was made after Ko refused to be questioned at night and attempted to leave the prosecutors’ office, the Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office said. Prosecutors were worried that he would collude with others involved in the case to make false statements if they allowed him to leave, so they issued an order to arrest him, the office said. Ko yesterday sought a court
ECONOMIC RESILIENCE: Only 11.4 percent of Taiwan’s overseas investments last year were in China, and businesses are dispersing their investments elsewhere, Lai said China’s ambition to annex Taiwan is based on a desire to change the rules-based international order, rather than a desire for territorial gains, President William Lai (賴清德) said in an interview. During an appearance on the talk show The View With Catherine Chang, aired last night, Lai said China aimed to achieve hegemony, and that peace and stability in the Taiwan Strait was an issue of worldwide concern. During the interview, Lai also discussed his “four-pillar plan” for peace and prosperity, which he first outlined in an article published by the Wall Street Journal on July 4 last year. That
‘GLOBAL THREAT’: MOFA said that it welcomes the ‘staunch US support’ and that ‘China again made spurious claims about Taiwan that do not accord with reality’ US National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan stressed the importance of stability in the Taiwan Strait, while a senior Chinese military official warned the US to stop “collusion” with Taiwan in a rare one-on-one meeting yesterday, both sides said. Sullivan arrived in Beijing on Tuesday, the first US national security adviser to visit China since 2016, for three days of talks with Chinese Minister of Foreign Affairs Wang Yi (王毅) and other high-ranking officials. Yesterday morning, Sullivan met with Zhang Youxia (張又俠), vice chairman of the Central Military Commission and China’s second-highest-ranking military official, at the Beijing headquarters of the commission.
GRAFT PROBE: Critics questioned Ko claiming he did not know about the Core Pacific floor area ratio issue until this year, citing a 2021 video in which he was asked about it Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) Chairman Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) was released without bail early yesterday, while his deputy during his tenure as Taipei mayor was detained and held incommunicado after being questioned since Friday over graft allegations related to a shopping center redevelopment project. Prosecutors on Saturday filed a request with the Taipei District Court to officially detain Ko and former Taipei deputy mayor Pong Cheng-sheng (彭振聲) over allegations surrounding the redevelopment of Core Pacific City, also known as Living Mall (京華城購物中心). The court yesterday determined that the evidence provided by prosecutors was insufficient to justify the detention of Ko and ordered his