Samsung Electronics Co could face fines running to billions of US dollars from the European Commission (EC) over its attempts to use its “standard-essential” patents (SEPs) on 3G to ban sales of Apple Inc’s iPhone and iPad in Europe.
The Google-owned smartphone company Motorola Mobility may face similar penalties over its attempts to ban sales of Microsoft Corp’s Xbox 360 through its use of patents relating to Wi-Fi and the H.264 video standard.
Both companies could receive fines in the US as well, where the Federal Trade Commission weighed in earlier this month in a court case between Motorola and Apple, arguing that Motorola’s use of SEPs amounted to a “hold-up.” Samsung is also being investigated by the US Department of Justice over its use of SEPs in cases against Apple.
The European Commission’s competition arm, run by Joaquin Almunia, issued a formal statement of objections on Friday.
The potential fines can run to 10 percent of a company’s worldwide turnover, which in Samsung’s case would amount to nearly US$15 billion, based on last year’s revenues of US$148.9 billion. The commission opened its investigation into Samsung in January.
Samsung and Apple have been battling each other through the courts — and seeking sales bans on each others’ products — in dozens of countries.
Apple has been seeking bans based on what it claims are infringements of specific patents that are not part of any standard, such as the “pinch and zoom” feature on touch screen phones, as well as design patents on the appearance of its products.
Samsung, by contrast, has frequently tried to use its SEPs, which differ from the patents asserted by Apple in that they are only included in a standard such as 3G if the owner makes a formal commitment to license them to all comers on a “fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory” basis. If the licenser and licensee cannot agree on pricing, it is set by a court. The commission said Apple had offered to make a payment, but that the two sides differed on the sums involved.
Just days before Almunia’s office moved against Samsung, the company announced that it was withdrawing its demands for sales bans on the iPhone and iPad in Europe — though the lawsuits, in which it is demanding payment for Apple’s use of the technologies, continue.
“Samsung remains committed to licensing our technologies on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms, and we strongly believe it is better when companies compete fairly in the marketplace, rather than in court. In this spirit, Samsung has decided to withdraw our injunction requests against Apple on the basis of our standard essential patents pending in European courts, in the interest of protecting consumer choice,” the company said.
However, it is continuing to seek sales bans via SEPs in other parts of the world, including the US, Asia and Australia.
Almunia argued in the statement that allowing companies that hold SEPs to ban sales where companies have not agreed pricing amounted to a “hold-up,” because “access to those patents which are standard-essential is a precondition for any company to sell interoperable products in the market.”
The European Commission decided that because Apple had offered to pay a licensing fee on the patents for 3G owned by Samsung, the Korean company’s demands for a sales ban were unjustified. “Recourse to injunctions harms competition,” it said.
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) yesterday obtained the government’s approval to inject an additional US$7.5 billion into its US subsidiary, the Department of Investment Review said in a statement. The department approved TSMC’s application of investing in TSMC Arizona Corp, which is engaged in the manufacturing, sales, testing and design of IC and other semiconductor devices, it said. The latest capital injection follows a US$5 billion investment for TSMC Arizona approved in June. The chipmaker has broken ground on two advanced fabs in Arizona with aggregated investments approved by the department totaling US$24 billion thus far. According to TSMC, the first Arizona
Her white-gloved, waistcoated uniform impeccable, 22-year-old Hazuki Okuno boards a bullet train replica to rehearse the strict protocols behind the smooth operation of a Japanese institution turning 60 Tuesday. High-speed Shinkansen trains began running between Tokyo and Osaka on Oct. 1, 1964, heralding a new era for rail travel as Japan grew into an economic superpower after World War II. The service remains integral to the nation’s economy and way of life — so keeping it dazzlingly clean, punctual and accident-free is a serious job. At a 10-story, state-of-the-art staff training center, Okuno shouted from the window and signaled to imaginary colleagues, keeping
STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIP: The plant would make infrared, gallium nitrade and silicon carbide chips as India attempts to develop a semiconductor value chain The US and India reached an agreement to work together on setting up a semiconductor fabrication plant in the South Asian nation, giving a boost to Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s efforts to bolster manufacturing in the country. The proposed plant would make infrared, gallium nitride and silicon carbide semiconductors, according to a White House readout that followed a meeting between US President Joe Biden and Modi in Delaware on Saturday. The setting up of the facility would be enabled by support from the India Semiconductor Mission and a “strategic technology partnership between Bharat Semi, 3rdiTech Inc and the US Space
Powerchip Semiconductor Manufacturing Corp (力積電) yesterday said that it signed an agreement with Tata Electronics Pvt Ltd to help build India’s first 12-inch chip manufacturing facility with a total investment of US$11 billion. As part of the agreement, Powerchip would provide Tata with access to mature technology nodes and help to train Indian workers, the Taiwanese company said in a statement. The fab would be located in Dholera, Gujarat. It would have a capacity of 50,000 wafers per month and create 20,000 jobs in the region, Powerchip said. Tata would receive access to a broad technology portfolio of leading-edge and mature nodes, including